Crime & Public SafetyJusticeState

Newsom Commutes 548 Death Sentences; Central Valley DAs Prepare Legal Challenge

Governor Gavin Newsom announced November 6 that he will commute all 548 death sentences in California to life without the possibility of parole. The decision, made two days after the November 3 election, drew immediate condemnation from district attorneys across the Central Valley and a promise of legal challenge from prosecutors.

Fresno County has 11 inmates whose sentences will be commuted under the order. Kern County DA Cynthia Zimmer stated November 6 that law enforcement officials are preparing a legal challenge to the governor’s action.

The commutations apply universally. Fresno County DA Lisa Smittcamp stated in a released statement that the governor did not review the individual circumstances of the condemned individuals as part of the clemency decision. Smittcamp said Fresno County cases involve murders of children, multiple victims, and calculated acts of violence, and that families have spent decades seeking justice.

Advertisement

Congressman Vince Fong (CA-20) issued a statement calling the timing political cowardice: “Gavin Newsom waited until two days after the election to overrule 548 death sentences. If he believed in this decision, he would have made it while voters could weigh in.”

The material cites three Fresno and Kern County cases by name. In 2004, Marcus Wesson was sentenced to death for murdering nine members of his own family in Fresno. In 2003, Vincent Brothers was sentenced to death for murdering five members of his own family in Bakersfield, including three children ages 4, 2, and six weeks. In 1994, Bob Williams was sentenced to death for breaking into a Bakersfield woman’s home, raping her, and murdering her.

Tulare County DA Tim Ward released a list of 13 death-row cases from his county, spanning 1988 to 2020. The list includes a 1996 conviction for the home-invasion rape and drowning murder of an 11-year-old girl; a 2006 conviction for five shotgun murders at a Tulare bar, Pato’s Place, after a $300 robbery; and a 2017 conviction for the sexual assault, beating, and torture murder of a three-year-old girl.

San Luis Obispo County DA Dan Dow stated November 6 that the governor “told the families of murder victims across California that the lives of the worst of the worst killers in our state are worth more than the lives of the innocent people they murdered.” Dow named three victims from his county: Rachel Newhouse and Aundria Crawford, kidnapped, raped, and murdered by Rex Allan Krebs; and Kesha Gurke, a 19-month-old girl tortured and murdered by Michael Whisenhunt. Both men were sentenced to death by San Luis Obispo County juries.

Dow stated that the California Constitution does not allow a governor to commute the sentence of a person twice convicted of a felony unless the California Supreme Court recommends it, with four justices concurring. Both Krebs and Whisenhunt are twice-convicted felons. Dow called on the Supreme Court to examine each case individually and hear from victims’ families and prosecutors before any recommendation is made.

Merced County DA Nicole Silveira stated that Officer Gray’s killer, Rivera, has prior felony convictions, meaning his commutation cannot take effect unless the California Supreme Court reviews his case and recommends it. Silveira’s office stated it will formally oppose Rivera’s commutation.

Jeannine M. Pacioni, president of the District Attorneys Association and Monterey County DA, stated families should have had a voice in the decision: “With the stroke of a pen, Governor Newsom has disregarded the decisions of hundreds of jurors and judges, and the anguish of families who lost loved ones to the worst crimes imaginable.”

Greg Totten, Chief Executive Officer of the California District Attorneys Association, stated November 6 that the governor made the decision “without giving those families or the prosecutors who represented them an opportunity to weigh in.”

Kern County DA Zimmer stated November 6: “I’m sure he didn’t know the names of the defendants or even the names of the victims. And he has left it for us, law enforcement and district attorneys in every county in California, to now begin the notification process to the families of those left behind whose loved ones were killed in the most heinous possible ways.”

The Breakdown

  • Newsom’s November 6 order commutes all 548 death sentences in California to life without the possibility of parole. The commutations are universal — no individual case review was conducted, per Fresno County DA Smittcamp.
  • The California Constitution bars a governor from commuting the sentence of a twice-convicted felon unless the California Supreme Court recommends it with four justices concurring. San Luis Obispo County DA Dow identified two death-row inmates in his county, and Merced County DA Silveira identified one, whose prior convictions mean their commutations cannot take effect without Supreme Court review. Silveira’s office stated it will oppose Rivera’s commutation; Dow called on the Supreme Court to examine each case individually.
  • Kern County DA Zimmer stated November 6 that law enforcement officials are preparing a legal challenge to the governor’s action. No further detail on the challenge’s legal basis or timeline was provided in the material.
  • California voters restored the death penalty in 1972, expanded it in 1978, refused to repeal it in 2012 and 2016, and voted in 2016 to make it work more efficiently, per San Luis Obispo County DA Dow.

What This Means for You

Governor Newsom’s November 6 order removed 548 death sentences two days after the November 3 election — a timing Congressman Fong called political cowardice because voters had no opportunity to weigh in at the ballot box. The governor substituted his judgment for every jury verdict, every judge’s review, and every California Supreme Court automatic appeal that upheld those sentences.

The legal constraint identified by San Luis Obispo and Merced County DAs — that twice-convicted felons cannot have sentences commuted without Supreme Court review — means the governor’s order is not final for an unspecified number of the 548 inmates. Whether the Supreme Court reviews those cases individually, and whether it hears from victims’ families and prosecutors as San Luis Obispo County DA Dow requested, is now the next decision point.

Kern County DA Zimmer stated that law enforcement officials are preparing a legal challenge to the governor’s action. No further detail on that challenge’s basis or timeline was provided in the material.

What to Watch

The material documents no cost breakdown, no process by which families were consulted, and no mechanism by which the 548 cases were reviewed before the commutations were issued. Fresno County DA Smittcamp stated explicitly that no individual review occurred. San Luis Obispo County DA Dow stated that the governor’s three-page announcement did not name a single victim; Kern County DA Zimmer stated she is sure the governor didn’t know the names of the defendants or the victims.

The constitutional constraint on commuting twice-convicted felons raises the question: how many of the 548 inmates fall into that category, requiring Supreme Court review? The material identifies three by name — two in San Luis Obispo County, one in Merced County — but does not state a total. If the number is substantial, the commutations are not final for a significant portion of the 548.

The material does not state the legal basis for the promised challenge from law enforcement. The timing of any filing and the court that would hear it are also unstated.

District attorneys and the DA association stated families were given no opportunity to weigh in before the decision was announced. The material documents only that Kern County DA Zimmer stated law enforcement is now beginning the notification process, not whether any notification occurred beforehand.

Voters rejected death-penalty repeal in 2012 and 2016 and voted in 2016 to make the penalty work more efficiently. The governor’s order reverses every one of those votes with a single signature. The question is whether the California Constitution’s clemency power was intended to permit a governor to nullify a penalty voters have repeatedly chosen to keep.

Related Coverage

Share this article Facebook X Pinterest LinkedIn Email

Leave a Reply

Advertisement Advertisement