Fresno Drops Flock Cameras After Breaches, Will Seek Replacement Vendor
Fresno will terminate its contract with Flock Safety when it expires in February 2027, following multiple documented security breaches. The city paid Flock $500,000 annually — $1.5 million across three years — through a state Organized Retail Theft Prevention Grant. Mayor Jerry Dyer and Police Chief Mindy Casto announced the decision on November 8, 2024, stating the company’s safeguards against unauthorized access have failed.
The city owns the camera hardware. It intends to contract with a different vendor to operate the automated license plate reader (ALPR) network.
Two breaches prompted the cancellation. A Fresno police officer is under investigation for misusing Flock cameras for reasons unrelated to any criminal investigation, according to Chief Casto. Separately, a Midwest police department accessed Fresno’s cameras years earlier, searching for what the system recorded only as “immigration.” California law prohibits police departments from sharing ALPR data with agencies outside the state.
Casto stated that Fresno does not share data with U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement. The department reported declines in murder, rape, assault, shootings, and burglary since 2021, which Casto attributed in part to the camera system.
Councilmember Nick Richardson plans to introduce an ordinance to regulate surveillance cameras citywide. The police department has its own ALPR policies, but Richardson said a city ordinance would bind future administrations. Councilmembers Mike Karbassi and Richardson will lead an ad hoc committee to review ALPR use and develop a framework for oversight.
Council member-elect Ariana Martinez Lott and Naindeep Singh, who leads in his uncalled race, have opposed the Flock contract. Dyer, Casto, and Richardson said their plans to replace Flock and draft regulations preceded the November 2024 election.
Flock Safety issued a statement saying it now tracks every search through a permanent audit trail and will require documented case codes for all law enforcement customers by the end of 2026. The company said it is implementing proactive lockout to suspend access when activity meets criteria for abnormal behavior.
The city is considering adding a feature that would link private cameras to the police network on a volunteer basis. City officials plan to discuss automated license plate readers at their December meeting.
The Breakdown
- Fresno’s three-year Flock Safety contract, signed in 2023, cost $500,000 per year for a total of $1.5 million in taxpayer money, funded through a state Organized Retail Theft Prevention Grant.
- The contract expires in February 2027 and will not be renewed. The city owns the camera equipment and will seek another vendor to operate it.
- Two documented breaches led to the cancellation: a Fresno officer under investigation for unauthorized use, and a past incident in which a Midwest department accessed Fresno cameras for a search labeled “immigration,” violating California’s prohibition on out-of-state data sharing.
- Councilmember Nick Richardson intends to introduce a citywide ordinance governing surveillance cameras, binding future administrations beyond current police department policies.
- An ad hoc committee led by Councilmembers Mike Karbassi and Nick Richardson will review ALPR use and develop an oversight framework. The council will discuss ALPRs at its December 2024 meeting.
What This Means for You
Your city government spent $1.5 million of state grant money on a surveillance system that two separate parties accessed for unauthorized purposes — one a Fresno officer, the other an out-of-state agency in apparent violation of California law. The mayor and police chief made the call to drop the vendor but keep the system running under a new company.
The incoming council includes members who opposed this contract. The city council will vote on Richardson’s proposed ordinance.
What You Can Do
The Fresno City Council will discuss automated license plate readers at its next meeting in December 2024.
What to Watch
The material names two breaches but provides no independent confirmation that these are the only two, no audit of how many searches the systems logged, and no accounting of which officers accessed what data when. Chief Casto says the department does not share data with ICE, but that statement rests on the same safeguards that failed to stop the Midwest department’s search and the Fresno officer’s misuse. What evidence would confirm her claim? A full audit trail, published, showing every search and every agency that requested or received data.
The city will seek another vendor to run the same cameras. What prevents the next company’s system from being breached the same way? The material gives no answer. Flock says it now requires documented case codes and tracks every search — but it said it had safeguards before, and they failed. The question is whether the replacement vendor’s audit log will be public, whether the ad hoc committee or Richardson’s ordinance will require it to be public, and whether any council member will demand to see that log before signing the next contract.
$1.5 million in taxpayer money, delivered through a state grant, went to a system that at least two parties misused. The mayor says crime is down and attributes it in part to these cameras, but crime has fallen nationally over the same period. How much of Fresno’s decline is due to the cameras, and how much would have happened regardless? The material provides no data isolating the cameras’ effect.
Richardson’s ordinance and the ad hoc committee are the mechanisms voters have to enforce accountability here. Will the ordinance require public reporting of every search? Will it mandate an independent review when breaches occur? Will the committee’s framework actually constrain future chiefs and mayors, or will it defer to their discretion? Those answers determine whether this system operates under real oversight or under reassurances that have already failed once.



