BusinessGovernmentLocal

Fresno Fire Fees Raised After Nearly a Decade — What You’ll Pay Now

The Fresno City Council voted March 19, 2020, to approve the 555th Amendment to the Master Fee Schedule, changing Fire Department fees for inspections and prevention services. The vote followed a 2011 consultant study that found the city was not recovering the cost of providing fire services — a gap that went unaddressed for nine years.

Fire Chief Kerri L. Donis recommended the changes in a staff report to the Council. The city hired NBS Government Finance Group in 2011 to analyze fire fees and concluded then that “overall fee levels were insufficient to recover the costs to provide services.” The Fire Department did not implement those recommendations at the time.

In January 2020, the city brought NBS back to review its own analysis of the 2011 study’s methodology. NBS agreed with city staff’s proposed changes, though the city did not commission a new comprehensive study. The Council adopted the fee changes, which are subject to the mayor’s veto.

Advertisement

The Breakdown

  • The 2011 study found Fresno was not charging enough to cover the cost of fire inspections and prevention services — the gap between what the city charged and what the services actually cost.
  • The Fire Department waited nine years to act on that study’s recommendations, leaving the fee schedule unchanged from 2011 until this March 2020 vote.
  • The city did not pay for a new full study in 2020 — instead, staff reviewed the 2011 consultant’s methodology themselves and asked the same consultant to sign off on their own work, which NBS did.
  • The resolution adds, adjusts, revises, or deletes “various Fire Department fees,” but the material does not state which specific fees changed, by how much, or what the new amounts are.

What This Means for You

The city has not disclosed the specific new fee amounts in this material — no dollar figures, no list of which fees went up or down, and no breakdown of who pays what. The Council’s vote changed the fee structure, but the material provides no concrete information about what you will actually pay if you own a business, rent commercial space, or live in a multi-family building that requires fire inspections.

This is a decision the Council made in a single vote, and the material names no public hearing, comment period, or advance notice to the businesses and property owners affected. As a voter, you have a right to know what the fees are, what they were, and why the gap went unaddressed for nearly a decade — and this material leaves all three questions unanswered.

What to Watch

The material does not state the dollar amounts of the new fees, the old fees, or the difference between them. It does not name a single specific service or inspection type affected. A voter cannot judge whether a fee change is reasonable without knowing what it is — and a Council vote that changes what residents and businesses pay, without stating the amounts in the public record, is exactly the kind of opacity that invites abuse.

The city’s process here raises a stewardship question: staff reviewed a consultant’s 2011 methodology themselves, proposed changes based on that review, and then asked the same consultant to confirm staff’s own work — which the consultant did, without performing a new comprehensive study. That is not an independent check; that is the city checking its own homework and calling it verified. What would actually verify these fees is a new, full cost-of-service study performed by someone with no stake in the outcome, along with a public breakdown of every fee, old and new, so voters can see what changed and why.

Why did the Fire Department wait nine years to implement a study it commissioned and accepted? The material offers no explanation. The gap between a study that says “you are not recovering costs” and a department that does nothing about it for nearly a decade is a gap voters deserve to see filled. If the delay was a matter of political will, say so. If it was a resource constraint, show the record. If it was simply inertia, that is itself an answer worth knowing.

Share this article Facebook X Pinterest LinkedIn Email

4 thoughts on “Fresno Fire Fees Raised After Nearly a Decade — What You’ll Pay Now”

Leave a Reply

Advertisement Advertisement