CandidatesElectionsLocal

District 1 Supervisor Runoff: Where Karbassi and Pacheco Stand on Libraries, Water, and Your Ballot

Fresno City Councilmember Mike Karbassi and Kerman Mayor Maria Pacheco face off in Tuesday’s runoff for the Fresno County Board of Supervisors District 1 seat. The winner will be one of three new supervisors joining the five-member board in January.

Karbassi finished first in the June primary with 8,046 votes to Pacheco’s 7,008 in a six-candidate field. The winner replaces Brian Pacheco, who has held the seat since 2014.

The race has centered on library privatization, Measure S, data centers, and water safety — issues that shape daily life for families across the district.

Advertisement Advertisement

The Breakdown

  • Library privatization: Both candidates oppose it. Karbassi warned the county would lose control and quality and called for expanding library access instead of pursuing short-term cost cuts. Pacheco said libraries provide internet access and educational programs critical for rural families and that she would not make decisions based on ideology.
  • Measure S support: Both back the sales-tax measure. Karbassi voted to support it on the Fresno City Council and said failure would create a major Fresno deficit, cost rural communities funding, and could lead to layoffs of workers like bus drivers. Pacheco supports it; Kerman adopted a resolution backing it, and she testified in Sacramento for AB 1923, which placed the measure on the ballot after county supervisors tried to delay it with a study. Pacheco cited the measure’s focus on established communities and roads over highway expansion as a reason for her support.
  • Data center moratorium: Both oppose data centers over water concerns. Karbassi pushed the Fresno City Council’s 10-year moratorium, citing that westside farms lack water and that communities like Kerman and San Joaquin face unsafe uranium and hexavalent chromium levels in drinking water. Pacheco said her stance reflects constituents who oppose data centers: “If they say no, it’s a no.”
  • Water quality clash: At a September 28 forum, Karbassi confronted Pacheco, holding Kerman water reports citing excess hexavalent chromium, uranium, and 1,2,3-Trichloropropane. “The water in Kerman isn’t clean,” he said, calling access to clean water a human right. Pacheco called his accusations “misleading,” saying she still makes Kool-Aid with Kerman tap water and that California lowered chromium limits, putting Kerman’s levels slightly above new restrictions but still safe to drink.

What This Means for You

This runoff decides who represents the majority-Fresno district on the county board for the next four years — a board with a consistently conservative majority. Your vote determines whose vision for rural library access, water safety standards, development priorities, and tax-revenue allocation shapes the district.

Karbassi, a Democrat endorsed by Republicans Garry Bredefeld and Margaret Mims, has touted his ability to work across party lines. Pacheco, endorsed by state Sen. Anna Caballero and Assemblymember Esmeralda Soria, has centered her campaign on supporting established communities over expansion and on listening to constituents.

The election is Tuesday, November 3, 2026. If you live in District 1 — which includes parts of Fresno, Kerman, San Joaquin, and westside communities — this is your chance to decide which candidate’s approach to water, development, and public services you trust.

What You Can Do

Vote by Tuesday, November 3, 2026. Check your registration and polling location at vote.fresnocounty.gov.

What to Watch

Karbassi has raised about $345,000 to Pacheco’s $169,000 — nearly two to one. About $121,000 of Karbassi’s total came after the June primary; about $105,000 of Pacheco’s came in the same window. Who funded that money, and what they expect in return, is worth asking.

Both candidates oppose library privatization and data centers and support Measure S — positions that align with broad public sentiment in the district. The real question is what each does when a decision pits popular opinion against a well-funded interest or a party ally. Karbassi’s Republican endorsements in a Democratic-held seat and Pacheco’s state legislative ties both create pressure points where a supervisor’s judgment will be tested.

On water quality, the candidates’ clash at the September forum is a preview of how they handle accountability. Karbassi cited Kerman water reports naming specific contaminants; Pacheco called the claim misleading and said the levels are safe to drink despite exceeding California’s lowered limits. A voter weighing this exchange should ask: what is the actual contaminant level, what is the current state limit, and what health risk does “slightly above” carry for a child drinking that water daily?

Related Coverage

Share this article Facebook X Pinterest LinkedIn Email

2 thoughts on “District 1 Supervisor Runoff: Where Karbassi and Pacheco Stand on Libraries, Water, and Your Ballot”

Leave a Reply

Advertisement Advertisement