Measure S Struggles, Measure D Leads as Fresno Voters Weigh Transportation Tax Replacements
Fresno County’s effort to extend its 30-year transportation tax is failing at the ballot box as of Wednesday, with early returns showing 53% of voters against countywide Measure S. Meanwhile, the city of Fresno’s backup plan — Measure D — is trending ahead with over 10,000 votes in the lead, according to reported election results.
Both measures sought to replace Measure C, Fresno County’s existing half-cent transportation sales tax, which expires in July 2027. Measure S proposed a 30-year countywide extension generating an estimated $7.5 billion over that period. Measure D, a city-only alternative placed on the ballot by Mayor Jerry Dyer and the council, would generate roughly $65 million per year for 10 years if activated.
Approximately 100,000 ballots remain uncounted. If Measure S passes despite the early count, Measure D does not take effect regardless of its vote total. If both fail, the county’s sales tax rate drops to 8.35% and the region loses its primary funding stream for road repairs and public transit operations.
The campaign for Measure S highlighted its structured spending plan: 65% of revenue allocated to local streets and roads, 25% to public transit, with the remainder split among regional highways, Safe Routes to School projects, bike lanes, and airport infrastructure. Former Fresno Mayor Ashley Swearengin, speaking at a Measure S watch party Tuesday night, framed the stakes in terms of infrastructure jobs and long-term needs. “Measure S means $7.5 billion going to our local transportation infrastructure, 68,000 jobs over the next 30 years,” Swearengin said. “This is just a basic thing to take care of our local communities. It’s for our kids and our grandkids.”
Critics of Measure S argued the measure created what they described as a “slush fund” for nonprofits and private organizations. Supporters disputed that characterization, but the material does not detail how the program’s allocation structure addresses that concern.
Measure S reached the November ballot after a legal fight. The Fresno County Board of Supervisors delayed placing the measure on the ballot, prompting supporters who had already gathered over 32,000 petition signatures. A Fresno County judge ruled in September that the measure could appear on the 2026 ballot.
Measure D functions differently. Revenue goes into the city’s general fund, with no mandated allocation. Mayor Dyer told a news outlet Wednesday that he anticipates continuing existing spending levels on roads and transit, with $12 million to $15 million per year potentially reserved for public safety — police and fire. “I would anticipate we’re going to continue to spend as we have in terms of our roads as well as transit. But there could be somewhere around $12-15 million a year that is reserved for public safety,” Dyer said.
Where Measure C restricted spending to transportation, Measure D allows the mayor and council to decide annually via the budget process how the money is used. The measure sunsets after 10 years or when county leaders adopt a similar tax.
The material states that 11 of Fresno County’s 15 mayors supported Measure S. A county spokesperson said the county is “evaluating next steps on a countywide tax” if Measure S fails.
The Breakdown
- Measure S: A countywide half-cent sales tax for 30 years, replacing the expiring Measure C. Revenue totaling an estimated $7.5 billion would be allocated by formula: 65% to local streets and roads, 25% to public transit, and the remainder to regional highways, bike lanes, Safe Routes to School, and airport infrastructure. Includes a Citizens Oversight Committee of residents and annual independent audits. Requires cities to bring road conditions to a minimum Pavement Condition Index of 70 (“good” condition) and guarantees zero-fare transit for students, seniors, people with disabilities, veterans, and active-duty military. Currently trailing with 53% voting no.
- Measure D: A city-only half-cent sales tax for 10 years, generating roughly $65 million per year. Revenue goes into Fresno’s general fund with no mandated allocation — the mayor and council decide spending annually. Mayor Dyer stated he anticipates $12 million to $15 million per year for public safety, with the rest continuing current road and transit spending, but the measure does not require that. Currently leading by over 10,000 votes.
- If Measure S passes: Measure D does not activate, no matter how many votes it receives. The countywide tax continues at the same half-cent rate, and Measure C’s expiration does not affect the tax rate.
- If both fail: Measure C expires in July 2027, the county sales tax rate drops to 8.35%, and the region loses its primary funding source for road repairs and transit operations.
What This Means for You
Your vote on Measure S decides whether the county keeps a dedicated transportation fund with a 30-year structure and defined allocations. Your vote on Measure D decides whether the city can independently maintain some transportation revenue if the countywide measure fails — but without any guarantee how future mayors and councils actually spend it.
If you live in the city and both measures fail, road and transit funding drops when Measure C expires next July. If you live outside the city and Measure S fails, you lose access to the countywide transportation tax entirely, since Measure D applies only within city limits. The material does not state what “evaluating next steps” means concretely or when county leaders would bring a replacement measure forward.
What You Can Do
Approximately 100,000 ballots remain uncounted. If you have not yet returned your ballot, you can still do so at the Fresno County Elections Office or an authorized drop box until the count is certified.
What to Watch
Measure D’s general-fund structure means there is no enforceable commitment to transportation spending beyond what the current mayor stated he “anticipates.” A future mayor or council majority could redirect the revenue to other city services — the measure’s language allows it. Whether the $12 million to $15 million Dyer mentioned for public safety represents new spending, a reallocation from other budget lines, or an offset against cuts elsewhere is not stated in the material and is not required to be disclosed under the measure.
If Measure S fails and county leaders “evaluate next steps,” the material does not indicate how long that process would take, whether it would involve another ballot measure or a different funding mechanism, or what happens to road repairs and transit service in the interim. The county spokesperson did not state a timeline or a specific plan.
For Measure S specifically, critics’ claim that the measure creates a “slush fund” for nonprofits and private organizations is not explained in the material — neither side’s argument is backed by a citation to the measure’s actual allocation formula or oversight structure. Supporters say the claim “misrepresents how the program would actually work,” but the material does not state what that misrepresentation is or provide the text or mechanism being disputed. A voter evaluating that criticism has no basis in this material to confirm or rule it out.


