Advertisement
GovernmentImmigrationLocalPublic Safety

Fresno City Council Bars ICE From Staging on City Property; DHS Calls Them ‘Sanctuary Politicians’

Fresno City Council voted 6-1 Thursday to ban ICE from using city-owned property — parks, parking lots, public buildings — to stage, process, or conduct immigration enforcement operations. The policy follows more than 200 ICE detentions across the Central Valley since early October and community complaints about staging at Roeding Park, downtown parking lots, and an August arrest at Fresno airport.

The Department of Homeland Security pushed back on the resolution and called Fresno officials “sanctuary politicians,” according to a DHS spokesperson quoted in the Fresno Bee. The spokesperson wrote that “ICE does NOT need to receive permission from local authorities to enforce federal immigration laws.”

Councilmembers Annalisa Perea and Nelson Esparza sponsored the resolution. Nick Richardson cast the only no vote.

Advertisement Advertisement

Mayor Jerry Dyer said he supports the policy as long as the city isn’t expected “to have armed police officers going out and confronting armed ICE agents. Because I can’t see any good come from that.”

Esparza said city employees and paid security will document and report attempts to use city property for enforcement, with the city attorney notified. He added the resolution “does not close public spaces to federal officers, and it does not interfere with legitimate criminal law enforcement.”

Perea said the city has jurisdiction over what operations stage on city sites and that the resolution “establishes reasonable boundaries.” She added: “Fear is crippling, and emotional fear is real, and nobody should have to fear whether or not it’s safe for them to walk out of their home.”

Gloria Hernandez, a legal observer with Valley Watch Network, has documented staging in downtown Fresno. Sukaina Hussain, deputy executive director of the California Immigrant Policy Center, said the effort was inspired by AB 1807, a state law taking effect in January that bans ICE staging on state-owned property. Fremont, Santa Rosa, and Alameda County passed similar ordinances recently.

“Local resources are for local communities,” Hussain said. “City places are paid for by public tax dollars, and should be utilized for the community that funds them.”

The council also voted 6-1 to extend the city’s project labor agreement with the Fresno, Madera, Tulare, Kings Building Trades Council through Dec. 31, 2031, and raised the minimum project cost covered by the agreement from $1 million to $2.5 million.

Projects under that threshold won’t be required to use union labor. Dyer blamed “inflation” of labor and material costs for the increase. City manager Georgeanne White said 59 projects subject to the agreement averaged over $4.7 million each.

Councilmember Miguel Arias opposed the higher threshold. “Going from 1 million to three and a half million is a 250% increase,” Arias said. “That, my friends, is not inflation. There is no way that anybody can justify a 250% increase in inflation for construction contracts.” He argued raising the threshold means fewer city jobs for local union workers who deserve good wages, health care, and retirement benefits.

Chuck Riojas of the Building Trades Council said he opposed the $2.5 million figure and that the city and union had already agreed to $3.5 million. The council settled on $2.5 million after debate.

Eric Christen, executive director of the Coalition for Fair Employment in Construction, called the project labor agreement “discriminatory against the 90% of the construction workforce that are union-free across California.” He added: “Your projects that have been placed under the PLA have been utter failures.”

During the first two years of the agreement, the city fell short of its goals for placing local residents in construction jobs.

The council unanimously approved a resolution to apply for a $15 million federal loan through HUD to expand affordable housing development and create a funding pool for nonprofit developers to purchase land and manufactured homes. The loan would be repaid through future Community Development Block Grant funds over 20 years.

The council unanimously voted to table Councilmember Nick Richardson’s ordinance to regulate automated license plate recognition (ALPR) technology until the Dec. 3 meeting. Arias and Perea wanted more community involvement. The proposal would bar vendors from giving another agency or national database default access to Fresno’s data without city authorization, ban facial recognition, prohibit vendors from using the city’s data for their own purposes, and require officers to give a specific reason for every search. It would require annual audits but not make them public.

The city’s contract with Flock Safety ends in February. A Fresno police officer is under investigation for allegedly abusing Flock cameras for reasons unconnected to a criminal investigation, according to a city report.

Crystal Rocha, co-founder of Rehop Fresno, said the grassroots group filed a public records request 82 days ago on Flock data and criticized Richardson for calling the resolution “an act of transparency.” She said: “What you’re proposing is out-of-date policy that doesn’t address the new capabilities of ALPR technology, but it sure does cover the city’s ass.”

Fresno resident David Bueller said the cameras need to be taken down entirely. “These systems are not secure; their effectiveness is questionable at best, and quite frankly, we should not be using them.”

The Breakdown

  • The ICE-restriction policy applies to city-owned parks, parking lots, recreation facilities, vacant land, and public buildings. It bans voluntary use of those properties for staging, processing, surveillance, or logistics in federal immigration enforcement. City employees and security will document and report unauthorized use to the city attorney. It does not close public spaces to federal officers or interfere with criminal law enforcement, according to Esparza.
  • The project labor agreement extension runs through Dec. 31, 2031. It covers city-funded public works projects costing $2.5 million or more, up from the previous $1 million threshold. Projects under that amount are not required to use union labor. The agreement sets wages, benefits, working conditions, and goals for hiring local residents and underrepresented groups. At least 50% of apprentice-level work hours must go to Fresno residents. The city must submit annual reports on implementation and local hiring results. If local hiring targets aren’t met two years after the amendment takes effect, the city and Building Trades Council must meet to discuss changes.
  • The $15 million HUD loan would fund affordable housing development and create a pool for nonprofit developers to buy land and manufactured homes. Repayment comes from future Community Development Block Grant allocations over 20 years.
  • The ALPR ordinance, tabled until Dec. 3, would regulate license-plate reader technology. It would bar vendors from sharing Fresno’s data with other agencies or national databases without city authorization, ban facial recognition, prohibit vendors from using the data for their own purposes, and require officers to justify every search. Annual audits would be required but not necessarily public.

What This Means for You

You elected this city council, and Thursday’s vote shows how that choice plays out in practice. The ICE-restriction policy means the city you pay property taxes to fund won’t voluntarily hand over its parks and parking lots for federal immigration enforcement — but DHS is already saying it doesn’t need permission, so the real test is what happens when ICE shows up anyway and whether the city actually enforces its own policy.

The project labor agreement means taxpayer-funded construction projects over $2.5 million will use union labor with set wages and benefits, while smaller projects won’t — the higher threshold means fewer projects covered, which is either fiscal restraint or fewer guaranteed local jobs depending on who you ask.

The ALPR decision got punted to December, so if you care whether the city tracks your car and who gets that data, the Dec. 3 meeting is when that gets decided.

What You Can Do

The next city council meeting is Dec. 3, when the ALPR ordinance comes back up. If you want to weigh in on whether the city should use license-plate readers, what restrictions should apply, or whether the audits should be public, that’s the meeting. Contact information for councilmembers is available on the city’s website.

What to Watch

DHS says it doesn’t need permission to enforce federal immigration law. The city says ICE isn’t welcome on city property. What happens the next time ICE stages at Roeding Park or a downtown parking lot? Does the city actually document it, report it, and challenge it, or does this policy turn out to be a statement with no enforcement behind it? The material names no penalty, no mechanism to stop ICE, and no answer to what the city does if federal agents ignore the policy. You’re being told the city “will not voluntarily offer” property — that word “voluntarily” is doing a lot of work. What’s the plan when it’s not voluntary?

On the project labor agreement: the city missed its local hiring goals for the first two years of the original agreement. The new version requires annual reports and a review process if targets aren’t met — but the material doesn’t say those reports will be public, and it doesn’t say what “discuss potential changes” actually means if the numbers stay bad. You’re being told this keeps taxpayer dollars circulating locally and ensures skilled work, but the record so far is that the local hiring targets weren’t hit. What’s different this time, and who’s checking?

The project labor agreement raises the threshold from $1 million to $2.5 million — a 150% increase, not the 250% Arias cited when comparing $1 million to the proposed $3.5 million that the Building Trades Council wanted. Dyer calls it inflation. Arias calls it a giveaway. The city manager says the average covered project was $4.7 million, which makes the new threshold sound reasonable — but that average includes the big projects that were always going to be covered. The question is how many projects in the $1 million–$2.5 million range won’t be covered now that would have been before. The material doesn’t give that number. Ask for it.

The $15 million HUD loan gets repaid out of future Community Development Block Grant funds over 20 years. That’s $15 million in federal money the city otherwise could have used for other CDBG-eligible purposes — street repairs, public facilities, services for low-income residents — now committed to loan repayment instead. The material doesn’t say what the interest rate is, what the total repayment will be, or what projects would have been funded with those CDBG dollars if this loan didn’t exist. You’re being told this “expands affordable housing,” which it might — but the cost is 20 years of forgone flexibility on how the city spends a major federal funding stream. What’s the actual return, and what’s the opportunity cost?

On ALPR: a Fresno police officer is under investigation for allegedly abusing Flock cameras for non-criminal reasons, according to a city report the material cites but doesn’t detail. The material doesn’t say what the abuse was, whether the investigation is complete, or what the outcome was. Richardson’s ordinance would require officers to justify every search — but the material says the ordinance “does not require the city to make those audits public.” An audit no one can see is not accountability. Who decided that audits should stay internal, and why? The city’s Flock contract ends in February. The ALPR decision isn’t whether to use the technology, it’s what rules apply when the city does. If you think the answer is “don’t use it at all,” the material shows residents saying exactly that at public comment, and the council ignored them.

Related Coverage

Share this article Facebook X Pinterest LinkedIn Email

Leave a Reply

Advertisement Advertisement