DevelopmentElectionsGovernmentHousing & DevelopmentLocalUrban Planning

Fresno City Council kills Mayor Dyer’s $4 billion SEDA project — election results forced the vote

The Fresno City Council voted 6-1 Thursday to table Mayor Jerry Dyer’s Southeast Development Area indefinitely — minutes before a packed public hearing was set to begin, and hours after election results showed three anti-SEDA candidates winning their races.

Councilmember Mike Karbassi made the motion around 4:45 p.m. Councilmember Miguel Arias seconded it. Councilmember Nick Richardson was the only no vote.

SEDA was a plan to annex and develop 9,000 acres of farmland in southeast Fresno, eventually building as many as 45,000 homes. Dyer pitched it as a $4 billion project. Opponents — residents, teachers, labor unions, three school districts — said it would close 11 schools citywide.

Advertisement Advertisement

What stopped it Thursday wasn’t the public hearing. It was the latest election count, released that afternoon by county clerk James Kus, showing anti-SEDA candidate Naindeep Singh ahead of his opponent. Singh, along with council candidates Ariana Martinez-Lott and Joaquin Arambula, had become fixtures at City Hall over the last year opposing the project.

“We would have been caught up in litigation only to undo this action in January,” Arias said after the vote. “Elections have consequences.”

Arias said approving SEDA in a lame-duck session would have been pointless — the new council would overturn it once sworn in next year.

Dyer said he was disappointed but not surprised. “We saw what was going to happen with the results of the election,” he told reporters after the meeting.

Councilmember Annalisa Perea, who just won a State Assembly race, said in a statement that “too many outstanding issues remained unresolved” despite years of planning. She added that “the question before us was not whether Fresno needs to plan for future growth, but whether the plan presented tonight was the right plan for our city.”

Southeast Fresno Councilmember Brandon Vang said his constituents had opposed SEDA through three campaigns. “The consensus of these three campaigns was that people in D5 didn’t want SEDA. The risk is so great. Why not invest in your current Fresno residents?”

The tabling came shortly after the Building Industry Association of Fresno and Madera Counties released an analysis projecting SEDA would generate $2.5 billion more in revenue than public costs over 15 years. That study, done by the National Association of Home Builders, assumed 1,500 homes built annually and projected $3.9 billion in local revenue against $1.4 billion in public costs.

Darren Rose, the association’s president, had said the project would “pay back its infrastructure in four years and then deliver a growing surplus for decades.”

Dillon Savory, executive director of the Central Labor Council, said before the vote that the city couldn’t afford the infrastructure investment while facing budget pressures and deferred maintenance. “There’s no money for this type of a project,” he said.

After the vote, Savory called it “the greatest policy win in some ways in the city of Fresno’s history.” He credited a coalition of residents, teachers, and labor unions for making SEDA the defining issue of this year’s election. “We created an amount of pressure where they had no way out,” he said.

Opponents who’d prepared for a marathon hearing Thursday night said they were relieved — but wary. “My biggest concern is the word ‘indefinitely,'” said southeast Fresno resident Brett Thompson. “I don’t want to see this thing come back.”

Fresno farmer David Ramming said the new council should vote it down for good in January. “We’d like to see it finished and them just vote no. Finish the thing!”

SEDA has been called a “zombie project” in Fresno — a plan that resurfaces every few years, pushed by a new mayor, only to collapse under the cost of building a new town from scratch.

The Breakdown

  • The council voted 6-1 to table SEDA indefinitely. Councilmember Karbassi made the motion, Councilmember Arias seconded it, and Councilmember Richardson was the lone no vote.
  • SEDA would have annexed 9,000 acres of farmland in southeast Fresno and eventually built as many as 45,000 homes. Phase 1 focused on South SEDA, east of Temperance Avenue and south of Jensen Avenue.
  • The Fresno Planning Commission recommended approval in August. The council was scheduled to hold a public hearing Thursday at 4 p.m., but tabled it before the hearing started.
  • Election results released Thursday afternoon showed anti-SEDA candidates Naindeep Singh, Ariana Martinez-Lott, and Joaquin Arambula winning their races. Councilmember Arias said approving SEDA now would be pointless because the new council would overturn it in January.
  • Opponents included Fresno Unified (which estimated SEDA could cause 11 schools to close), Central Unified, Sanger Unified, the Central Labor Council, teachers, and residents.
  • Supporters included the Building Industry Association, which released a study projecting $2.5 billion more in revenue than public costs over 15 years, assuming 1,500 homes built annually.

What This Means for You

The council’s vote means SEDA won’t move forward under this council. Whether it stays dead depends on what the new council does in January when Singh, Martinez-Lott, and Arambula are sworn in.

If you voted for those three candidates because of SEDA, this is the result you voted for — the outgoing council blinked rather than approve something the incoming council would undo. If you supported SEDA, the project you wanted is shelved unless a future council revives it.

This is also what happens when a mayor’s signature project runs into organized opposition and election consequences. Dyer spent years pushing this. Residents, teachers, and unions spent years pushing back. The election settled it.

What You Can Do

The new council — with Singh, Martinez-Lott, and Arambula — will be sworn in January 2027. If you want SEDA formally rejected, not just tabled, watch for when that council takes it up and show up to that meeting or contact your councilmember before it happens.

What to Watch

“Tabled indefinitely” is not the same as “voted down.” The motion keeps SEDA alive on paper. A future council could bring it back.

Opponents want the new council to kill it outright in January. The Building Industry Association’s $2.5 billion surplus claim assumes 1,500 homes built every year for 15 years and compares total projected revenue to total projected public costs. The association’s study looked at a 15-year buildout of 22,500 homes, while the city’s own consultant looked only at the smaller Phase 1. Those are not the same analysis.

The claim that SEDA would cause 11 schools to close comes from Fresno Unified’s estimate. Councilmember Vang asked directly Thursday night — “Why not invest in your current Fresno residents?”

Related Coverage

Share this article Facebook X Pinterest LinkedIn Email

2 thoughts on “Fresno City Council kills Mayor Dyer’s $4 billion SEDA project — election results forced the vote”

Leave a Reply

Advertisement Advertisement