Advertisement
ElectionsLocal

Measure S Fails, Measure D Passes: Fresno Splits on Transportation Tax

Fresno County voters rejected Measure S 53.38% to 46.62%, ending a half-cent countywide transportation sales tax after 40 years. City of Fresno voters approved Measure D, keeping the same tax rate but shifting control from transportation-only to general-fund spending.

Measure S would have replaced Measure C — the expiring half-cent sales tax first approved in 1986 — and run 30 years. It projected $7.4 billion for road repairs, transit, bike lanes, and safety upgrades countywide. The measure lost by over 9,100 votes as of Wednesday, with roughly 100,000 ballots uncounted.

Measure D passed within city limits, keeping Fresno’s current 8.35% sales tax rate unchanged. Unlike Measure C, which restricted spending to transportation, Measure D deposits revenue into the city’s general fund. Mayor Jerry Dyer stated the city would continue current road and transit spending, with “somewhere around $12–15 million a year” reserved for police and fire. The measure sunsets after 10 years or when the county adopts a similar tax.

Advertisement Advertisement

Measure S cleared over 32,000 signatures to qualify for the ballot but faced a legal battle after the Fresno County Board of Supervisors delayed placing it before voters. A Fresno County judge ruled in September the measure could proceed to this year’s ballot.

Former Fresno Mayor Ashley Swearengin, speaking at a Measure S watch party, cited “$7.5 billion going to our local transportation infrastructure, 68,000 jobs over the next 30 years.” Critics argued the measure created a “slush fund” for nonprofits and private organizations. Supporters said that claim misrepresented the program. The measure had support from 11 of the county’s 15 mayors.

A county spokesperson stated the county is “evaluating next steps on a countywide tax” if Measure S fails.

The Breakdown

  • What Measure S would have done: Continued the existing half-cent countywide transportation sales tax (Measure C, in place since 1986) for 30 years, beginning July 2027. Projected $7.4 billion over 30 years for road repairs, transit service, bike lanes, sidewalks, and traffic safety countywide. The measure states 65% of annual revenue would go to fixing and maintaining roads, 12–15% to disadvantaged unincorporated communities, and guaranteed $400,000 base allocations to every jurisdiction regardless of size. Required jurisdictions to bring roads to a Pavement Condition Index of 70 out of 100 (a standard measurement where 100 is perfect pavement and lower numbers indicate greater deterioration). Guaranteed zero-fare transit for students, seniors, people with disabilities, veterans, and active-duty military. An 11-member Citizens Oversight Committee of non-politicians would review audits and track spending via a public online database. The rate would not have changed — it continues the same half-cent tax voters approved decades ago.
  • What Measure D does: Continues the city’s current 8.35% sales tax rate, but shifts revenue from transportation-only to the general fund. Mayor Dyer stated the city would keep current road and transit spending but reserve “somewhere around $12–15 million a year” for police and fire. Sunsets after 10 years or when the county adopts a similar tax.
  • Current status: Measure S lost 46.62% to 53.38%, down by over 9,100 votes, with roughly 100,000 ballots uncounted as of Wednesday. Measure D is leading in city-only results.

What This Means for You

If you live outside Fresno city limits, the countywide transportation tax that funded road repairs, transit, and safety projects since 1986 is ending. If you live inside city limits, the same tax rate continues, but the city now controls how it’s spent — Mayor Dyer and the city council can direct up to $12–15 million a year to police and fire instead of transportation.

This is a real shift in who decides and what they can fund: Measure C locked the money into transportation projects distributed across the county under a formula and citizen oversight. Measure D puts the city’s share into general spending with no restrictions.

What You Can Do

The county spokesperson stated the county is “evaluating next steps on a countywide tax.” Watch for announcements from the Fresno County Board of Supervisors and the Fresno Council of Governments on whether and when a new countywide measure will be proposed.

What to Watch

The sources document $7.4 billion in projected revenue over 30 years from Measure S, but do not state how much of that was taxpayer money versus private financing, tax credits, or other sources. The sources also do not state how the $68,000 jobs figure or the $7.5 billion figure cited by Ashley Swearengin were calculated, or whether those estimates included indirect or induced effects.

Mayor Dyer’s “somewhere around $12–15 million a year” reserved for police and fire under Measure D is stated as an estimate, not a binding allocation — the actual amount will depend on future city budgets and council votes, which are not restricted by Measure D’s language.

The sources state critics argued Measure S created a “slush fund” for nonprofits and private organizations, and that supporters said the claim misrepresented the program — but the sources do not state what evidence either side offered to back those positions, what the actual distribution formula was, or who would have received contracts or funding under Measure S.

The sources also do not name the opponents who challenged the measure beyond the “slush fund” claim, or detail what the legal battle over ballot timing concerned beyond the Board of Supervisors’ delay.

Who benefits: The sources do not state who would have received the contracts, construction work, or consulting fees funded by Measure S, or whether any specific developers, transit operators, or contractors stood to profit.

Under Measure D, the sources state the city will continue current transportation spending, but the $12–15 million shift to police and fire means those departments gain funding flexibility at the potential expense of transportation projects that would otherwise have been funded.

Who loses: Residents outside Fresno city limits lose the dedicated transportation funding Measure C provided since 1986 unless the county passes a new tax. If the county does not act, road repairs, transit service, and safety projects in unincorporated areas and smaller cities will depend on general-fund allocations competing with other priorities.

Inside the city, transportation projects lose the guarantee of dedicated funding — the city can choose to maintain current spending levels, but Measure D does not require it.

Related Coverage

Share this article Facebook X Pinterest LinkedIn Email

Leave a Reply

Advertisement Advertisement