GovernmentHousingLocalPublic Safety

City’s Thin-Material Pipes Flood Homes; 400-Year Replacement Plan Now ‘Too Long’

A water main installed 30 years ago broke open early Nov. 10, flooding homes in southeast Fresno with up to three feet of water and leaving families displaced. The pipe was built with thinner material the city used during the 1980s and 1990s.

Betty Gaona’s family had no time to react. “As soon as he told me, the water rushed in and all my family, you know, got into our cars,” she said. Water destroyed floors, appliances, and belongings.

Down the street, Cindy Alvarez lost an iron gate, motors, and part of a stucco wall. A tree in her yard toppled after the water saturated the surrounding soil. “First I started hearing crackling, so I looked and then I noticed it fell so fast,” she said.

Advertisement

Fresno Public Utilities Director Paul Amico says the city picked the thinner pipe material during a growth period. “There was a period in time when the city constructed these 16-inch water mains out of a thinner material, and this was in the 80s and 90s when the city was undergoing a lot of growth,” Amico said. “It was a material that was selected at the time that has not proven to be as durable as the current materials that we’ve been using.”

The city’s current replacement plan assumes water mains last 400 years. Amico says the city is now considering cutting that to 100 years. Other pipes made with the same thin material have been flagged for replacement “over the coming years.”

Alvarez, a mother of two with pets, had no confirmed housing the night of the break. The city later found her temporary housing, but she couldn’t move in that night and slept at her flooded home. “I have two kids and I have pets, and there’s no clear answers,” she said.

The city has not said what the repairs will cost. Amico says officials “hope to discuss accelerating water main replacements with the city during the next round of water rate discussions.”

The Breakdown

  • The pipe that broke Nov. 10 was built 30 years ago with thinner material the city used in the 1980s and 1990s.
  • The city’s current replacement cycle assumes water mains last 400 years before needing replacement.
  • The utilities director says the city is considering shortening that cycle to 100 years, meaning pipes originally expected to last centuries would be replaced much sooner.
  • Other pipes made with the same thin material have been identified as priorities for replacement “over the coming years.”
  • The city plans to discuss accelerating replacements during the next water rate discussions.

What This Means for You

You’re paying water rates set by a city council that approved a 400-year replacement cycle for infrastructure that’s failing at 30 years. The next rate discussion will decide whether you pay more to replace these pipes faster — and whether the city explains how many more of these thin-material pipes are still in the ground under your neighborhood. The gap between what the city promised these pipes would do and what they actually did is the gap between the infrastructure plan you’re funding and the one that actually works.

What to Watch

The city says it identified other thin-material pipes as “high priority for replacement over the coming years,” but won’t say how many, where they are, or what “coming years” means. A voter funding a faster replacement cycle through higher water rates should know the full scope — how many miles of this material are still in use, what the replacement cost is, and whether the city will publish a neighborhood-by-neighborhood map of where these pipes are before the next one breaks under someone else’s home.

The utilities director says the city “selected” thinner material during rapid growth in the 1980s and 1990s. That’s a choice — build cheaper now, or build to last. The pattern worth naming: when a city picks the cheaper option during a boom, the bill comes due later, and it’s the residents flooded out at 1 a.m. who pay it first. The city hasn’t said what these repairs cost, and hasn’t said whether it will seek reimbursement from anyone — a contractor, a manufacturer, an insurer — or whether ratepayers will simply cover it.

Alvarez had no confirmed housing the night her home flooded, even after the city said it would provide temporary housing. She slept at her damaged home with two kids and pets. That’s not a plan — that’s a gap between what the city says it’s doing and what actually happened. What’s the city’s actual protocol for displacing residents when its own infrastructure fails, and did it follow that protocol here?

Related Coverage

Share this article Facebook X Pinterest LinkedIn Email

Leave a Reply

Advertisement Advertisement