Fresno Ends Flock Camera Contract, Plans Replacement Vendor by Year-End
Fresno will not renew its contract with Flock Safety for automated license plate readers, Mayor Jerry Dyer announced Nov. 6. The city expects to select a replacement vendor by the end of 2026.
The decision follows what Fresno Police Chief Mindy Casto identified as unauthorized searches of Fresno’s Flock data by out-of-state law enforcement agencies — an issue city leaders say is unique to Flock’s software. Some searches specified “immigration” as the reason, though those came from local agencies, not the federal government, according to Casto.
Councilmember Nick Richardson is drafting a policy that would set standards for future vendors, including a 30-day data retention limit and auditing procedures. The Fresno City Council reviews that proposed policy Thursday, Nov. 12.
Between January and October 2026, Flock technology helped solve 42 of 128 shootings and 16 of 25 murders, Casto said at the Nov. 6 news conference.
Axon is one potential replacement. Fresno signed a five-year, $18.3 million contract with Axon in 2024 for 800 body-worn cameras, unlimited data storage through Evidence.com, and other products. The Fresno Bee reported that Axon has a “technology-testing relationship with the Fresno Police Department in exchange for steep discounts.”
Los Angeles dropped Flock earlier in 2026 and moved to a pilot program with Axon, the Los Angeles Times reported. Fresno officials said they reached out to the LAPD and other agencies as they revisit their vendor guidelines.
Privacy advocates say the problem is the technology itself, not just Flock. “If Fresno is considering alternatives like Axon or Motorola or whoever, these systems all carry risks,” said Nick Hidalgo, a senior attorney at the American Civil Liberties Union of Northern California. “They all capture a ton of our sensitive location information and allow cops to search that information with almost no cause.”
Dave Maass with the Electronic Frontier Foundation called switching to Axon “even more frightening than Flock,” citing the risk of a “mega-surveillance system” that integrates license plate readers with body-worn cameras, live video analytics, and investigative data platforms.
A 2020 state audit of Fresno PD’s license plate reader policies — then under vendor Vigilant Solutions, since acquired by Motorola — pushed the department to update its data retention and other policies. “They’re just going to hit the same problems again,” Maass said.
Ian Adams, an associate professor at the University of South Carolina, co-authored a working paper (still awaiting peer review) that found an 11% decrease in motor vehicle theft attributable to Flock cameras. He said studies have not yet confirmed claims that the technology solves violent crimes. “Police agencies tell us that it is, but there’s no study yet that has shown that in black and white numbers,” Adams said.
“Our residents deserve privacy protections, transparency, and accountability,” Richardson said at the Nov. 6 news conference. “Our officers deserve clear guidelines that allow them to do their jobs. We believe that we can accomplish both.”
The Breakdown
- Fresno will not renew its Flock Safety contract. The city expects to select a replacement vendor for automated license plate readers by the end of 2026.
- The decision followed unauthorized searches of Fresno’s Flock data by out-of-state agencies. Some searches cited “immigration” as the reason; those came from local agencies, not the federal government.
- Councilmember Nick Richardson drafted a policy setting standards for future vendors: a 30-day data retention limit, auditing procedures, and a requirement that users provide “sufficient detail to identify the authorized law enforcement purpose.” The council reviews the policy Thursday, Nov. 12.
- Fresno holds a five-year, $18.3 million contract with Axon (signed 2024) for body cameras, data storage, and other products. Axon has a “technology-testing relationship” with Fresno PD in exchange for discounts.
- Richardson’s draft policy largely mirrors Senate Bill 34 (2015 state law). One provision — requiring detailed search reasons — goes beyond SB 34, according to Hidalgo. The draft does not require audit logs to be made public.
What This Means for You
The council’s vote Thursday determines what safeguards govern how the next vendor’s cameras track Fresno residents’ movements — and whether the public will ever see how officers use that data. The policy sets retention limits and search requirements, but leaves the audit logs that would show abuse out of public reach. Whether those logs remain internal to the department or become public record is the difference between oversight the public can verify and oversight the public is asked to trust.
What You Can Do
The Fresno City Council reviews Councilmember Richardson’s proposed vendor policy Thursday, Nov. 12. Public comment procedures for council meetings are available at fresno.gov.
What to Watch
Fresno pays Axon $18.3 million over five years for body cameras and data storage. The question is whether adding license plate readers to that relationship creates the “mega-surveillance system” Maass described — body cameras, live video, and location tracking integrated under one vendor with access to all three datasets. The material does not state what Fresno would pay the replacement vendor for the license plate readers themselves, or how much the city paid Flock under the contract it is ending.
Richardson’s draft requires officers to provide “sufficient detail” justifying each search, but does not require audit logs to be made public. A public records request from the Electronic Frontier Foundation found officers entering “lmao” or “haha” as search reasons under the prior vendor — abuse uncovered only because those logs were accessible. The draft leaves that access question unresolved. What independent check exists to verify officers are providing the required detail, and not repeating the pattern documented under the last system?
Adams said independent auditing — performed by a third party, not the department or the vendor — is necessary for public trust. The draft does not specify who conducts the audits Richardson’s policy requires.
Casto credited Flock with helping solve 42 of 128 shootings and 16 of 25 murders in 2026. Adams said no peer-reviewed study has confirmed that license plate readers solve violent crimes. His own working paper found an 11% decrease in motor vehicle theft — property crime, not violent crime. The gap between the claims and the studies is what Adams called “not the end of the debate.”
Related Coverage
- District 1 Council Candidates Both Oppose Renewing Fresno’s $1.5 Million Flock Camera Contract
- Fresno Police Chief Apologizes to City Council Candidate After Toxicology Test Clears Him of DUI Allegation
- City Council approves $20,000 annual deal to share sex offender registration office with County Sheriff




Pingback: Fresno Drops Flock Cameras After Breaches, Will Seek Replace