City’s Cheap Pipes Flood Southeast Fresno Homes — Replacement Timeline Could Stretch Decades
A city water main burst early Monday morning in southeast Fresno, flooding homes with as much as three feet of water, forcing evacuations, and leaving at least one family’s home red-tagged as unsafe to live in.
The pipe that failed was installed roughly 30 years ago using thinner material the city picked during rapid growth in the 1980s and 90s — material that Fresno Public Utilities Director Paul Amico now says “has not proven to be as durable as the current materials that we’ve been using.”
Betty Gaona and her family had no warning. Water rushed into their home on Clovis Avenue around 1 a.m., destroying floors, appliances, and belongings. “As soon as he told me, the water rushed in and all my family, you know, got into our cars,” Gaona said. The family is now in a hotel, indefinitely. Gaona is unemployed; her husband is disabled. “It’s hard for us right now. It’s hard, but we have to sleep somewhere,” she said.
Down the street, Cindy Alvarez watched floodwater destroy her newly-built iron gate, crack a stucco wall, and ruin the motors on the gate. Five hours after the break, a tree in her front yard toppled over — the soil underneath so saturated it couldn’t hold the roots. “First I started hearing crackling, so I looked and then I noticed it fell so fast,” Alvarez said.
The city is promising to reimburse hotel expenses and cover damaged belongings. Families can call 311 for temporary housing at no cost, the city says. But the timeline for repairs is unclear — officials told residents it could take days, weeks, or months.
Amico says the city is now considering shortening its water main replacement cycle from 400 years to 100 years. That means pipes the city once expected to last centuries may need replacement far sooner. Other water mains made with the same thinner material “have been identified as a high priority for replacement over the coming years,” Amico said. He told reporters officials hope to discuss accelerating replacements with the city during the next round of water rate discussions.
The city has not said how much of the potentially faulty piping remains in use, whether the manufacturer provided a warranty, or where else similar pipes have already failed. FOX26 submitted a public records request for that information but had received no response at the time of reporting.
For Gaona, the failure is more than a personal crisis — it’s a warning. “If there’s something else in other parts of the city, it’s like a ticking bomb,” she said.
The Breakdown
- A 16-inch water main on Clovis Avenue burst around 1 a.m. Monday, Nov. 9, flooding homes and creating a massive sinkhole.
- The pipe was installed approximately 30 years ago using thinner material the city chose during rapid growth in the 1980s and 90s — material the Public Utilities Director now says has “not proven to be as durable” as current materials.
- The city is considering shortening its water main replacement cycle from 400 years to 100 years, meaning pipes expected to last centuries may need replacement far sooner.
- Other pipes made with the same material have been identified as “high priority for replacement over the coming years,” according to Public Utilities Director Paul Amico.
- The city promises to reimburse hotel expenses and cover damaged belongings for affected families, who can call 311 for temporary housing.
- At least one home has been red-tagged as unsafe to live in; the city says recovery could take months.
What This Means for You
You’re looking at a city infrastructure program that bet on cheap materials 30 years ago and is now admitting those materials don’t hold up — while the timeline for replacing the rest of those pipes is measured in years, not months.
Amico said officials hope to discuss accelerating replacements during “the next round of water rate discussions,” but didn’t say when that discussion happens or how much it would cost.
If you live in southeast Fresno or anywhere the city laid these thinner pipes in the 80s and 90s, this failure is your preview — the director himself called similar pipes elsewhere “a high priority,” which means the city knows where they are and hasn’t replaced them yet.
The city won’t say how much of this piping is still in the ground or whether it’s failed elsewhere before. That’s a record you’re entitled to, and the city’s silence on it is its own answer.
What You Can Do
If you were affected by the flooding, call 311 to request temporary housing at no cost and ask about reimbursement for hotel expenses and damaged property. The city has committed to covering those costs but has not released a formal process or timeline.
If you want to know where else this thinner piping is still in use, how much of it remains, and whether the city has a funded replacement schedule, submit your own public records request to the City of Fresno — FOX26 did exactly that and had received no response at the time of their reporting. You can also attend City Council meetings and ask directly during public comment when the water rate discussion Amico referenced will happen and what the actual replacement timeline and cost estimate are.
What to Watch
The city says it will reimburse expenses and cover damage, but the material gives no process, no timeline, no claim form, and no dollar cap. Will the city actually make displaced families whole, or will residents end up fighting for reimbursement months from now? What’s the mechanism, and who verifies the claims?
Amico says officials “hope to discuss” accelerating replacements with the city during “the next round of water rate discussions” — when is that, and how much would it cost? A replacement cycle shortened from 400 years to 100 years is still a replacement cycle where a 30-year-old pipe that just failed won’t be on the list for another 70 years unless the city moves faster. What’s the actual funded schedule, and how much of the at-risk piping gets replaced in the next five years versus the next fifty?
The material names no independent check on whether the piping that failed was defective, whether the city accepted a product that didn’t meet spec, or whether the manufacturer stands behind it. Amico calls it a “material that was selected at the time” — selected by whom, on what basis, and did anyone get a warranty? That’s exactly the kind of detail a public records request would show, and the city’s failure to respond to one is worth noting.
Gaona calls it “a ticking bomb” if similar pipes are elsewhere in the city. The city has identified other high-priority sections but won’t say how many, where, or how soon they’ll be replaced. A voter weighing a future water rate increase or a council member’s infrastructure record needs that answer, not a press-event reassurance that it’s being handled.


Pingback: City's Thin-Material Pipes Flood Homes; 400-Year Replacement