
City tax for roads and police heads toward passage as countywide plan struggles — Photo: T.P. Wilson and A.R. Romine — Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons
City tax for roads and police heads toward passage as countywide plan struggles
Fresno families relying on city road repairs and emergency services may see that funding continue — but outside city limits, transportation projects could be left without money.
As of Wednesday, early results show the city’s Measure D — which keeps the current sales tax rate the same but shifts how the money can be spent — leading in the polls. Meanwhile, the countywide Measure S, a half-cent transportation tax meant to replace the expiring Measure C, is trailing with 46.62% support against 53.38% opposition, down by over 9,100 votes.
Measure D was placed on the ballot as a backup after Measure S faced strong opposition and a legal battle over whether it could even appear on the November ballot.
Former Fresno Mayor Ashley Swearengin, speaking at a Measure S watch party Tuesday night, framed the stakes in generational terms. “Measure S means $7.5 billion going to our local transportation infrastructure, 68,000 jobs over the next 30 years,” she said. “This is just a basic thing to take care of our local communities. It’s for our kids and our grandkids.”
The final outcome depends on roughly 100,000 ballots still waiting to be counted.
The Breakdown
- Measure S is a half-cent, 30-year countywide sales tax that would replace Measure C, Fresno County’s current half-cent transportation sales tax. Supporters say it would bring in $7.5 billion over 30 years (roughly $246 million annually), with 65% directed to roads and 25% to public transit. Students and veterans would ride FAX buses for free if it passes.
- Measure D is the city of Fresno’s backup plan. It keeps the current 8.35% sales tax rate the same but changes where the money goes. Unlike Measure C, which can only be spent on transportation, Measure D puts the money into the city’s general fund — meaning it can be used for police, fire, and other city services in addition to roads and transit. Mayor Jerry Dyer said he expects “somewhere around $12-15 million a year” could be reserved for public safety.
- Measure D would sunset after 10 years, or sooner if county leaders adopt a similar countywide tax.
- If Measure S fails and Measure D passes, the city of Fresno will have its funding protected, but unincorporated areas and smaller cities across the county could lose transportation dollars when Measure C expires. A county spokesperson said they are “currently evaluating next steps” if Measure S fails.
What This Means for You
Your vote on these two measures determines who gets money for roads, buses, and emergency services — and who doesn’t. If Measure D passes and Measure S fails, the city of Fresno keeps its funding, but your neighbors outside city limits lose theirs. If Measure S passes, the entire county — city and unincorporated areas alike — gets 30 years of transportation money, but the city of Fresno won’t have the flexibility to spend that money on police and fire that Measure D would allow.
This is also a test of whether the city’s backup plan — putting Measure D on the ballot after Measure S faced opposition — was the right call. If you live in the city, you’re voting on whether you want a narrower pot of money shared countywide (Measure S) or a more flexible city-only fund (Measure D). If you live outside the city, you’re voting on whether the county gets transportation funding at all.
What You Can Do
The election is still being counted. If you haven’t returned your ballot yet, you can track the next ballot count update through the Fresno County Elections Office. Results will continue to be updated as the remaining roughly 100,000 ballots are processed.
What to Watch
Mayor Dyer said Measure D would reserve “somewhere around $12-15 million a year” for public safety, but the material doesn’t state where that figure comes from, how it was calculated, or what the total annual revenue from Measure D is expected to be. A voter weighing this measure should know the full revenue picture and whether that $12-15 million estimate is the city’s projection, a maximum, or a share that could shrink depending on other priorities. The budget documents or staff report behind that figure would answer it.
The material also doesn’t state what happens to county transportation projects if Measure S fails and county leaders don’t act quickly enough to fill the gap. A county spokesperson said they are “evaluating next steps,” but that evaluation is happening after the vote, not before — meaning voters outside the city are being asked to decide without knowing what the county’s actual backup plan is. Who designed that timeline, and why wasn’t the county’s plan ready before voters had to choose?
Measure S faced “strong opposition from some leaders and residents” and was “the subject of a legal battle” over whether it could appear on the ballot, according to the material — but the material doesn’t name who opposed it, what the legal challenge was, or why it generated that level of conflict. Supervisor Garry Bredefeld is quoted in earlier campaign material calling Measure S “a public transportation tax, funding buses that people don’t ride and creating bike lanes that people don’t use and don’t want,” and earlier reporting described a dispute over an Access and Innovation Program that critics called a “slush fund” for nonprofits. The material doesn’t state whether those criticisms are what drove the legal fight or the opposition that made Measure D necessary. A voter should know what the actual objections were and whether they were resolved or simply bypassed by putting Measure D on the ballot instead.
If Measure D passes, it shifts transportation money into the general fund, where Mayor Dyer and the city council decide how to spend it. The material doesn’t state whether the city has committed to maintaining current road and transit spending levels, or whether the flexibility to spend on police and fire could mean less money for roads over time. A budget commitment or spending policy would show whether road funding is protected or just a priority the mayor expects to continue. Why isn’t that commitment in writing?
Related Coverage
- Fresno Mayor Dyer Condemns Federal Immigration Sweeps as Threat to Community Trust and Local Economy
- Fresno Mayor Dyer’s Armenia Trip Centers Trade, Agriculture, and Honoring Genocide Victims
- Six Candidates Compete for Three Fresno City Council Seats — Mayor Dyer Warns of ‘Rough Last Two Years’ If Wrong People Win



