Fresno County Supervisors Green-Light 300-Foot Blast Mine Despite State Warning of ‘Catastrophic’ Risk to $44M Salmon Investment
The Fresno County Board of Supervisors voted 3-2 on Thursday, November 12, to approve a modified version of CEMEX’s Rockfield quarry expansion — a 300-foot-deep blast mine on the banks of the San Joaquin River that will run for 63 years. The approval came despite an in-person recommendation from the California Department of Fish and Wildlife to reject the project over what the agency’s Central Region manager called a “catastrophic” risk to the state’s salmon restoration effort.
Board Chair Garry Bredefeld and Supervisors Nathan Magsig and Buddy Mendes voted yes. Supervisors Brian Pacheco and Luis Chavez voted no. The decision overturns an October deadlock by the Fresno County Planning Commission, which failed to approve the project after a 3-3 vote with three commissioners absent. CEMEX appealed the same day.
CEMEX, a Mexico-based building materials company, originally sought to drill 600 feet into hard rock over 100 years. The board instead approved a scaled-down alternative recommended by county staff: a 300-foot pit with a 63-year permit. The pit must stay at least 300 feet from the river and 150 feet from Friant Road. Blasting would occur once or twice a week on weekdays between 10 a.m. and 2 p.m., starting within the next few years, according to CEMEX attorney Patrick Mitchell.
Julie Vance, regional manager for the California Department of Fish and Wildlife, told supervisors the state just built a $44 million conservation hatchery less than two miles upstream from the mine site, and that salmon spawn directly next to it. She warned that a breach during a flood could introduce chemicals into the river.
“Once there is a pit of this size immediately adjacent to an active river channel, it will open up a liability for hundreds of years with no feasible means to undo the damage,” Vance said. “Given the resources at stake, I am asking you to deny the appeal and protect the substantial investment made in the San Joaquin River by the taxpayers of this state.”
No supervisor asked Vance follow-up questions about the risks she described. Sharon Weaver, executive director of the San Joaquin River Parkway and Conservation Trust, said after the vote that an experienced state official told her she couldn’t recall supervisors ignoring a Fish and Wildlife recommendation like this at any other time in her career.
As part of the approval, CEMEX must agree to pay Fresno County’s legal costs if anyone sues over the decision. In letters to the county, attorneys for the San Joaquin River Parkway and Conservation Trust have argued the project’s environmental review violates state law.
About 120 people spoke during a two-hour public comment period split evenly between supporters and opponents. Many supporters were CEMEX workers, union members, and contractors. Ricky Phillips, an Operating Engineers Local 3 member, told supervisors he is a third-generation miner on the site. “I’m proud to say I’m working the same ground my grandfather and dad retired from. We’re able to make a good living and raise a family from the wages and material the Rockfield facility provides.”
Neighbors and environmental groups cited blasting impacts on water, wildlife, and property values. One resident who lives within 200 feet of the project said, “Our home values will drop 30%. How many of you are going to compensate for our loss? When we built our homes there, nobody said there would be deep blast mining.”
Vance also told supervisors the state issued CEMEX a notice of violation in August because the company’s plant site extends onto about 14 acres of state land. Mitchell said that problem started before the state bought the property and that CEMEX is working on a land swap.
Late in the meeting, Bredefeld negotiated with CEMEX for an additional voluntary payment — up to $150,000 a year in about a decade for City of Fresno roads, on top of the 5 cents per ton (about $150,000 annually) CEMEX had already offered to the county. Weaver criticized the deal: “It’s really disappointing to me that Supervisor Bredefeld, who expressed concerns about roads, then accepted this pittance CEMEX threw out as a negotiating tactic. You can barely pave a driveway for $150,000. What good is that going to do for roads?”
Supervisor Luis Chavez said after the vote that the timing was deliberate. “Let’s not tiptoe around the issue. There are times to be upfront. The reason this waited to come before this board is because of the election cycle. This project was ready long before. It was deliberately postponed in order to minimize the criticism and blowback.”
Three of the five supervisors on the board will be out of their seats by January. Supervisor Buddy Mendes agreed the project was likely ready for a vote months earlier, but said the election had nothing to do with the delay.
CEMEX and the companies before it have mined rock, sand, and gravel at the site since at least 1913, according to county records. Its current permits expire in July 2027. The new plan allows CEMEX to dig below the river gravel into hard rock for the first time.
The Breakdown
- The Fresno County Board of Supervisors voted 3-2 on November 12 to approve a modified version of CEMEX’s quarry expansion at the Rockfield site on Friant Road near Willow Avenue along the San Joaquin River.
- The approval allows CEMEX to blast into hard rock and excavate a pit up to 300 feet deep over 63 years. The original proposal sought 600 feet over 100 years.
- Blasting would occur once or twice a week, on weekdays between 10 a.m. and 2 p.m. The pit must stay at least 300 feet from the river and 150 feet from Friant Road.
- As a condition of approval, CEMEX must pay the county’s legal costs if anyone sues over the decision. Attorneys for the San Joaquin River Parkway and Conservation Trust have already argued in letters to the county that the project’s environmental review violates state law.
- CEMEX must also return to the board at the 10-year and 30-year marks to demonstrate compliance with county requirements.
- The California Department of Fish and Wildlife recommended denial, warning of “catastrophic and irreparable impacts” to the San Joaquin River if the pit is breached during a flood. The state built a $44 million salmon hatchery less than two miles upstream, and salmon spawn next to the mine site.
- CEMEX received a notice of violation in August because the company’s plant site extends onto about 14 acres of state land. CEMEX says it is working on a land swap to resolve the issue.
What This Means for You
Three supervisors you elect — Garry Bredefeld, Nathan Magsig, and Buddy Mendes — just voted to authorize a private company to blast and excavate a 300-foot pit next to a public river for the next 63 years, over the objection of the state agency responsible for protecting the fish your tax dollars are being spent to restore.
That $44 million hatchery investment is now at risk of being “catastrophically” damaged if the pit floods, according to the state’s own regional manager. The vote overrode a tied Planning Commission vote and ignored the state’s direct ask to deny the project.
If you live near the site, your property value exposure is unmitigated. If you care about the salmon run or the river, the liability Sharon Weaver described — “a mine like this doesn’t go away, we’re left with the problems forever” — is now locked in for longer than most voters will be alive.
The timing also matters: Supervisor Luis Chavez said on the record that the project was ready months ago and was deliberately held until after the election to avoid blowback, and three of the five supervisors who voted will be gone by January.
What You Can Do
Attorneys for the San Joaquin River Parkway and Conservation Trust have stated in letters to the county that the project’s environmental review violates state law, and CEMEX is required by the approval to pay the county’s legal costs if anyone sues. If you want to join or support a legal challenge, contact the San Joaquin River Parkway and Conservation Trust.
If you live in Supervisor Nathan Magsig’s district (the area where the project is located) and want to hold him accountable for this vote, his term continues and he remains reachable through the Fresno County Board of Supervisors. Supervisors Bredefeld, Magsig, and Mendes cast the deciding votes — their names are the ones to remember.
What to Watch
CEMEX profits directly from this approval — 63 years of extracting and selling construction materials from a site the company already owns, with no land acquisition cost. The company originally sought a Jesse Morrow Mountain site in the 2010s but abandoned it after supervisors rejected the plan when the mountain was found to be a Native American burial site.
The $150,000-per-year voluntary road payment Bredefeld negotiated — characterized by Sharon Weaver as “a pittance” that “can barely pave a driveway” — is the only additional public benefit extracted in exchange for 63 years of private profit and public risk.
Nearby residents face property value losses — one resident stated a 30% drop — with no county fund to make them whole. The salmon run itself, and the wildlife Weaver said would be impacted by blasting, bear ecological costs with no representation at the table.
The state’s own warning — “catastrophic and irreparable impacts,” with “no feasible means to undo the damage” and “a liability for hundreds of years” — describes a risk the county is authorizing a private company to create next to a public resource.
Julie Vance’s testimony that an experienced state official couldn’t recall supervisors ignoring a Fish and Wildlife recommendation like this raises the question: what drove three supervisors to override the agency tasked with protecting the very resource taxpayers just spent $44 million to restore?
Supervisor Luis Chavez stated on the record that the project was ready months before the vote but was deliberately held until after the election to avoid criticism. Three of the five supervisors who voted — including the three who voted yes — will be out of office by January, insulated from voter consequences.
CEMEX is also operating on 14 acres of state land without authorization, per the state’s August notice of violation. The company says it’s working on a land swap, but the sources provide no timeline, no terms, and no confirmation that the swap will happen before the blasting starts.
The project requires CEMEX to return at the 10-year and 30-year marks to demonstrate compliance. What happens if the company isn’t in compliance — does the county have the authority to halt operations, or only to ask for a report?
A 63-year approval is longer than most careers, longer than most elected terms, and longer than the institutional memory of the offices that will oversee it.



