Fresno City Council Votes to Block ICE From Using City Property as Staging Areas
The Fresno City Council voted Thursday to restrict Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents from using city-owned property — parks, parking lots, buildings, garages — for staging or running immigration enforcement operations unless agents have a valid judicial warrant or court order.
Councilmember Miguel Arias said ICE has been using downtown garages and the Tower Theatre parking lot as staging areas “on a daily basis.” The resolution passed with one no-vote: Councilmember Nick Richardson, who called it “just words on a page” without a real enforcement plan.
Over a dozen residents testified in support. “I myself as a female that is a brown woman I face fear. I am on the lookout for all those license plates out there and I shouldn’t even have to do that,” resident Eileen Hernandez said.
Mayor Jerry Dyer said he spoke with Department of Homeland Security and White House officials earlier this week, called ICE’s tactics “archaic,” and questioned what consequences ICE agents would face for violating the policy. “I just hope that there’s not an expectation that we are going to have armed police officers going out and confronting armed ICE agents because I can’t see any good from that,” Dyer said.
Councilmember Annalisa Perea acknowledged no implementation plan exists yet. The city manager and city attorney are now tasked with developing one. No deadline was set.
The vote comes as advocacy groups report a sharp increase in ICE activity across the Central Valley. Valley Watch Network typically receives 300 to 500 reports of ICE activity per month; over the past couple of months, that number has jumped to between 2,600 and 3,000 reports per month, the organization says.
Nora Zaragoza-Yanez of Valley Watch Network said enforcement has increased “a lot more in these past couple weeks in the North Valley think Merced all the way up to San Joaquin County.” The group reports enforcement operations occurring throughout the day and night.
“People are being racial profiled. They’re being stopped at traffic stops. Their vehicles windows are being broken in. Excessive use of force, without display of a judicial warrant or warrant for someone’s arrest,” Zaragoza-Yanez said.
Images circulating in recent weeks show an incident in Fresno in early October in which ICE agents pulled a man from his work truck. In Kerman, a farmworker’s car window was smashed as he drove home from work.
Flor Martinez Zaragoza, with Celebration Nation nonprofit, said families are relying on neighbors for groceries and school runs. “Right now, families are trying not to leave their homes. They’re depending on their neighbors to help them with their groceries to take their kids to school, when they do leave their homes they’re living under this panic mode this anxiety, depression stress.”
Last month, Congressman Jim Costa and other California lawmakers sent a letter to Acting ICE Director David Venturella demanding answers about Central Valley detentions. They still have not received a response, according to the material. Last week, Costa and Sen. Alex Padilla made an unannounced visit to the Golden State Annex ICE detention facility in McFarland and were turned away.
The Breakdown
- The resolution restricts ICE agents from using city-owned parks, parking lots, and buildings for immigration enforcement operations unless they have a valid judicial warrant or court order.
- Federal officers are allowed to use areas open to the public and to follow valid court orders for non-immigration enforcement.
- The city manager and city attorney are now responsible for developing implementation guidance for city staff — no deadline or enforcement mechanism has been set.
- The vote was led by Council President Nelson Esparza and Councilmembers Annalisa Perea and Miguel Arias. Nick Richardson was the sole no-vote.
What This Means for You
You voted for every member of this city council. This resolution is their response to reported allegations of racial profiling, broken car windows, and stops advocates say happened without warrants — and to ICE using taxpayer-funded city property as a base for operations. Whether it actually changes anything depends on a plan that doesn’t exist yet and an enforcement mechanism nobody has explained. Mayor Dyer’s question — what happens when ICE ignores this — is the same question you should be asking the council that passed it.
What to Watch
The city manager and city attorney are supposed to produce an implementation plan. No deadline. No stated consequences for ICE if they ignore it. Mayor Dyer openly questioned whether the city would send “armed police officers going out and confronting armed ICE agents” — he can’t see any good from that, and neither should you. What’s the plan if ICE shows up at a city garage tomorrow? Who enforces this resolution, how, and at what risk?
Councilmember Richardson’s no-vote wasn’t about the goal — it was about calling this what it is without a plan: “just words on a page.” Other cities have done this — Alameda County issued a cease and desist letter to ICE, and cities like Fremont and Santa Rosa passed similar resolutions, according to Sukaina Hussain of the California Immigrant Policy Center, who said local law enforcement cars on traffic patrol “are used to go usher folks out of those spaces.” Does Fresno have the same enforcement capacity, or the same willingness to confront federal agents? The material doesn’t say.
The resolution itself raises the question: restricting where ICE can stage is not the same as restricting what ICE can do. A family afraid to leave home because enforcement operations are happening “throughout the day and night” across the valley — as Valley Watch Network reports — is not safer because those operations can’t use a city parking lot. The council voted on where ICE can park. The enforcement activity the advocates described — racial profiling, broken car windows, stops without judicial warrants — is a federal action the city has no authority over.
Valley Watch Network’s numbers — a jump from 300–500 reports per month to 2,600–3,000 — are self-reported. That’s not a reason to dismiss the pattern, but it is a reason to ask what independent data confirms it.
Finally: Congressman Costa and other California lawmakers sent a letter to Acting ICE Director David Venturella last month demanding answers about Central Valley detentions. They have not received a response. Costa and Sen. Padilla were turned away from an ICE detention facility in McFarland last week. If ICE won’t answer a member of Congress, why would it answer a city council resolution with no stated enforcement mechanism?


