GovernmentLocal

Fowler Residents Hit With $3,700 Water Bills as City Admits 900 Meters Are Faulty

A Fowler resident’s October water bill jumped from the usual $40 a month to more than $3,700, part of a billing crisis the city now ties to more than 900 outdated water meters scattered across the small Fresno County city. Sophia Suarez said the eye-popping charge applied if paid after Oct. 15, and it wasn’t an isolated glitch — residents and business owners across Fowler have spent months watching their water bills swing wildly, from nothing at all to thousands of dollars.

Suarez’s bill is one of the more dramatic examples to surface as city officials have scrambled to explain the problem. According to Mid Valley Times, more than 900 of the city’s roughly 2,500 water meters are older models that require hand-checking, and officials say incorrect billing varies case by case and is sometimes caused by faulty meters. Mayor Juan Mejia has pointed to a combination of faulty antennas and outdated equipment, according to KMPH, which also reported that roughly 900 meters had been identified as outdated or misread and could be contributing to the unexpectedly high bills.

When a meter registers zero consumption, the city defaults to charging a baseline rate of $29.05 for 12,000 gallons, per the Mid Valley Times report — a workaround that has itself produced confusing results for households that then see a corrected or estimated bill land later. That pattern, zero-dollar charges followed by sudden corrections, has shown up repeatedly among both residential and commercial customers.

Advertisement

The complaints are not new. KMPH reported that Fowler residents have been flagging unusually high water bills for roughly four months. Mejia told the city council that one resident showed him five months of bills with totals that were, in his words, “all over the place.” Mejia has described the billing swings as something of a roller coaster for residents and commercial customers alike, and has acknowledged that the city has been slow to correct meter problems while remaining quick to send out bills.

Part of the confusion traces back to 2020, when Fowler used grant funding to replace more than 1,000 aging water meters, according to the same KMPH report. City officials now believe some of the meters left in place since that upgrade may be contributing to today’s billing problems.

Financially, the stakes go beyond individual households: the city is currently only recovering about 50% of its water-related costs through customer bills, per Mid Valley Times, relying on reserve funds to cover the shortfall.

City staff have outlined a six-point corrective plan that includes reviewing manual meter reads, investigating radio-read failures, testing meters, reconciling audits against billing records, and reporting account corrections back to the city council, Mid Valley Times reported. Fowler’s city manager has said the city has not cut off water service over nonpayment on any of the disputed high bills, and officials say they are reviewing refund requests and billing corrections on an individual, case-by-case basis.

The issue is scheduled to come back before the council at the Nov. 17 meeting, when staff are expected to present a contract to replace some of the remaining outdated meters. Mejia has conceded the city needs to identify meter problems and respond to complaints faster going forward, with the stated goal of installing new meters and reading them regularly to cut down on the corrected and estimated bills that have frustrated residents for months.

Suarez, whose bill typically runs under $40 a month, told reporters the $3,700 charge nearly gave her a heart attack. She said what residents need most from the city now is clearer communication and transparency about why bills have swung so unpredictably, and when the problems will actually be fixed.

The Breakdown

  • More than 900 of Fowler’s roughly 2,500 water meters are older models that require hand-checking, and officials say incorrect billing varies case by case and is sometimes caused by faulty meters.
  • When a meter registers zero consumption, the city defaults to charging a baseline rate of $29.05 for 12,000 gallons — a workaround that has produced confusing results when corrected or estimated bills land later.
  • Part of the confusion traces back to 2020, when Fowler used grant funding to replace more than 1,000 aging water meters; city officials now believe some of the meters left in place since that upgrade may be contributing to today’s billing problems.
  • The city is currently only recovering about 50% of its water-related costs through customer bills, relying on reserve funds to cover the shortfall.
  • City staff have outlined a six-point corrective plan that includes reviewing manual meter reads, investigating radio-read failures, testing meters, reconciling audits against billing records, and reporting account corrections back to the city council.
  • The city has not cut off water service over nonpayment on any of the disputed high bills, and officials say they are reviewing refund requests and billing corrections on an individual, case-by-case basis.

What This Means for You

If you live in Fowler, your water bill may have been wrong for months — either too high or too low — and the city has been slow to fix it while still sending bills out. The city’s acknowledgment that it is only recovering half its water costs through customer bills shows there is a shortfall being covered by reserve funds. The Nov. 17 council meeting is when staff are expected to present a contract to replace some of the remaining outdated meters.

What You Can Do

The Nov. 17 Fowler City Council meeting is when staff are expected to present a contract to replace some of the remaining outdated meters. Attend that meeting to hear the city’s plan and to speak during public comment if your water bill has been affected. Contact the city directly to request a review of your bill if you believe you have been overcharged — the city manager has said they are reviewing refund requests and billing corrections on a case-by-case basis.

What to Watch

The Nov. 17 contract presentation should clarify how much the city is committing to replace the remaining outdated meters and how long the replacement will take. Residents have been complaining for four months, and the city has acknowledged it has been “slow to correct meter problems while remaining quick to send out bills” — Mayor Mejia’s own words.

The city says it is only recovering 50% of its water-related costs through customer bills and is relying on reserve funds to cover the shortfall. The sources do not explain whether customers who have been undercharged will see corrected bills, or who will ultimately cover that shortfall.

The city used grant funding in 2020 to replace more than 1,000 aging water meters, but city officials now believe some of the meters left in place since that upgrade may be contributing to today’s billing problems. The sources do not explain why 900 meters were left in place during a replacement project or whether the city knew at the time that the remaining meters were outdated.

Share this article Facebook X Pinterest LinkedIn Email

Leave a Reply

Advertisement Advertisement