Advertisement
GovernmentImmigrationLocal

Fresno City Council Sets Aside $1 Million in Taxpayer Money for Immigrant Legal Defense Fund

The Fresno City Council voted 5-1 on Thursday to establish a $1 million legal defense fund for immigrants in the city facing deportation proceedings — the largest single allocation the city has made for this purpose. The money will come from salary savings generated by keeping city positions unfilled.

Councilmember Miguel Arias, who sponsored the measure, said demand for legal assistance has increased significantly in recent weeks amid what he and other officials describe as heightened Immigration and Customs Enforcement activity in Fresno and the Central Valley. “We’ve seen in these recent ICE raids, citizens and legal immigrants have also been picked up and victimized, including those who are undocumented. They have a right to due process,” Arias said.

The fund is restricted to Fresno residents who have not been convicted of any criminal offense. Councilmember Nick Richardson cast the lone no vote. Council Vice President Tyler Maxwell was absent. Mayor Jerry Dyer, who previously described the proposal as premature, has the authority to veto the measure.

Advertisement Advertisement

Two residents spoke against the proposal during public comment. Niel O’Brien argued that if the concern is due process when government acts badly, “the answer is simple — make the fund available to any Fresno resident harmed by government or political abuse.” Arias defended the allocation by comparing it to legal assistance the city provides in eviction cases. “Eviction is a civil matter. Immigration is a civil matter. We have invested more than $6 million representing those who are legally evicted who are residents of Fresno. This is no different,” he said.

Seventeen speakers urged the council to approve the fund. Sukaina Hussain, deputy executive director of the California Immigrant Policy Center, told the council that immigrants detained by ICE often face deportation in just a couple of days with no right to a court-appointed attorney. “Having a lawyer and having a fund that can provide support for this attorney can severely change that outcome and can help keep families together,” she said.

The city has previously funded immigration legal defense, though at much smaller levels. In 2022, Fresno spent $200,000 on 18 immigration cases — eight remain open, and ten were completed successfully. In 2023, the city spent $100,000 on 17 cases; sixteen remain open, and one was completed successfully. In 2025, the city budgeted $100,000 for the program but instructed legal staff not to open any new cases.

The city attorney’s office said many cases remain unresolved because outside legal counsel is still awaiting documents, other cases are pending with U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services, and some hearings are scheduled years into the future.

State Assemblywoman Esmeralda Soria joined demonstrators outside City Hall following the vote. She had announced $3 million in state funding for Central Valley community organizations that support immigrant families. “We’re saying ICE out. We want them to stop doing what they’re doing. They are racially profiling people regardless of if they are citizens or not. And our families are scared,” Soria said.

The Breakdown

  • The Fresno City Council voted 5-1 to create a $1 million legal defense fund for immigrants facing deportation proceedings.
  • The money comes from salary savings — keeping city positions vacant rather than filling them.
  • Only Fresno residents with no criminal convictions are eligible for the legal aid.
  • Councilmember Miguel Arias sponsored the measure, citing increased ICE activity and detentions of citizens, legal immigrants, and undocumented residents in recent weeks.
  • The fund addresses a gap in immigration court: there is no right to a court-appointed attorney in deportation cases, meaning detained residents can face removal in days without legal representation.
  • Mayor Jerry Dyer can veto the measure. He has previously called the proposal premature and said he tries not to duplicate what other government entities or nonprofits are already doing.
  • The city previously allocated smaller amounts for immigration legal defense: $200,000 in 2022 (18 cases, 10 completed successfully) and $100,000 in 2023 (17 cases, 1 completed successfully). Many cases remain open years later, waiting on documents, agency decisions, or hearing dates.

What This Means for You

This vote directs $1 million of taxpayer money toward legal representation for immigrants facing deportation who have no criminal record. The council made this choice by a 5-1 vote, with funding coming from keeping city positions vacant rather than filling them.

The city’s track record shows that of 35 immigration cases funded in 2022 and 2023, 11 were completed successfully while 24 remain open. The city attorney’s office says cases remain unresolved because outside legal counsel is still awaiting documents, other cases are pending with U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services, and some hearings are scheduled years into the future.

If Mayor Dyer vetoes this, the council would need a supermajority to override him. That vote would show you which councilmembers think this fund is worth fighting for and which ones are willing to let the mayor’s veto stand.

What You Can Do

Mayor Jerry Dyer has the authority to veto this measure. If you want to weigh in on whether he should, you can contact his office at (559) 621-8000 or through the city’s website at fresno.gov.

The Fresno City Council meets on Thursdays. You can attend meetings in person at City Hall, 2600 Fresno Street, or watch online at fresno.gov/council. Public comment is open to any resident.

What to Watch

The sources do not state how much of the $1 million will go to attorneys’ fees, how much will go to administrative costs, or how the city will select which cases to fund. They also do not state whether the fund will prioritize residents based on family circumstances, length of residency, or urgency of deportation timelines — or whether it will operate on a first-come, first-served basis.

The council voted to fund this program by keeping city positions vacant. The sources do not state which positions are being kept vacant or what services those unfilled jobs would have provided.

In 2022 and 2023 combined, Fresno spent $300,000 on 35 immigration cases. Of those, 11 were completed successfully — meaning 24 cases remain open. The city attorney’s office says the delays are due to waiting on documents, agency backlogs, and hearing dates scheduled years out. The sources do not state whether the city tracks attorney performance, whether it has terminated contracts for attorneys who don’t close cases, or whether it has any accountability mechanism beyond waiting for scheduled hearings.

Two speakers opposed the fund during public comment. Niel O’Brien raised a question about why legal aid isn’t available to any Fresno resident harmed by government or political abuse, regardless of immigration status or case type. The sources do not indicate how the council responded to this question.

Mayor Dyer called this proposal premature and said he tries not to duplicate what other entities are already doing. The sources do not state what entity he believes is already providing this service, how much funding that entity has, or whether it has the capacity to handle the volume of cases.

State Assemblywoman Esmeralda Soria announced $3 million in state funding for Central Valley organizations that support immigrant families. The sources do not state whether that $3 million includes legal defense, whether it overlaps with the city’s $1 million fund, or whether the two are funding separate services.

Councilmember Miguel Arias said ICE raids have picked up “citizens and legal immigrants” as well as undocumented residents. The sources do not state whether any of the cases the city has funded in the past involved citizens wrongfully detained, or whether the fund covers only immigration court proceedings or also federal civil-rights claims.

Related Coverage

Share this article Facebook X Pinterest LinkedIn Email

Leave a Reply

Advertisement Advertisement