
Fresno City Council Waives Convention Center Audit After Pandemic Year, Opts for Lighter Review — Photo: Erik Drost — CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons
Fresno City Council Waives Convention Center Audit After Pandemic Year, Opts for Lighter Review
The Fresno City Council voted in December 2021 to let the Convention Center’s private manager skip a required independent audit of the facility’s finances for Fiscal Year 2021, replacing it with a less detailed review by the city’s external auditor.
The council approved an amendment to the city’s contract with ASM Global Fresno, LLC — the company hired in June 2020 to run the Convention Center — that removes the audit requirement for that year only. Both the city administration and ASM agreed the audit was “unnecessary” because the pandemic shut down most Convention Center activity in FY 2021.
Instead of the contractually required audit, which the city and ASM were supposed to fund jointly, the city accepted a commitment from its external auditor, Brown Armstrong, to conduct a “review” of the Convention Center’s FY 2021 finances as part of the firm’s broader Annual Comprehensive Financial Report audit.
The original 2020 contract called for an annual audit of the Convention Center’s financial results for each year of the contract’s term. The amendment waives that requirement for FY 2021 only, according to the staff report from Finance Director Michael Lima.
The Breakdown
- The city’s contract with ASM Global required a joint-funded annual audit of the Convention Center’s finances every year.
- The city administration and ASM agreed to skip the FY 2021 audit, citing “minor financial activity” during the pandemic shutdown.
- The council replaced the audit with a “review” by Brown Armstrong, the city’s external auditor, as part of that firm’s city-wide annual audit.
- The waiver applies only to FY 2021 — the annual audit requirement remains in place for other years of the contract.
What This Means for You
When the City Council votes to replace an independent audit with a review, it’s deciding how closely taxpayer money at the Convention Center gets scrutinized. Voters weighing the council’s judgment on spending oversight need to know when that scrutiny gets dialed back, even if the reason given is that “not much happened” during a shutdown year.
What to Watch
The material doesn’t state how much the city was paying toward the joint-funded audit, what the review by Brown Armstrong cost, or whether the city saved money by making the switch — only that both parties agreed it was “unnecessary.” A real question is what “minor financial activity” actually means in dollar terms and whether shutting down operations is a reason to watch finances more closely, not less.
Who decided what counted as minor, and what records would show whether the city’s money was actually tracked through a year when the usual revenue wasn’t coming in? The staff report and the Brown Armstrong correspondence would answer that, but the material doesn’t say either is available to the public. Another question: if a pandemic year with “minor activity” didn’t need a full audit, what does that say about the accountability standard for years when activity picks back up?



