ElectionsJusticeNational

DOJ Drops California Ballot-Challenge Suit After Midterm Losses, Leaves Grand Jury Probe Active

The Trump administration’s Justice Department moved Nov. 6 to dismiss its lawsuit demanding California set aside roughly 20,000 ballots from alleged noncitizens, days after Republicans lost ground in the midterm elections. The dismissal came a week before a court-appointed special master was scheduled to evaluate the accuracy of the DOJ’s list — a list California officials and the presiding federal judge both called unreliable.

The lawsuit, filed in mid-October after hundreds of thousands of ballots had already been processed, sought to force election workers to segregate mail ballots from people the DOJ claimed lacked citizenship. U.S. District Judge David O. Carter, appointed by former President Bill Clinton, rejected the request in late October, writing that separating ballots at that stage would “wreak havoc” on the midterms and risk disenfranchising citizens. A federal appeals panel — including one Trump-appointed judge — upheld that denial Oct. 30.

Federal prosecutors told the court Nov. 6 that by the time of the scheduled hearing, California would have “already irreparably commingled the challenged ballots with lawful ones,” making the relief sought “no longer available.” Judge Carter closed the case Nov. 10 with a one-paragraph order condemning the suit as an attempt to “disrupt an ongoing election and create confusion and uncertainty for voters and election workers alike.”

Advertisement

The lawsuit’s dismissal does not end the Justice Department’s scrutiny of California elections. Federal grand jury subpoenas issued to Los Angeles County election officials in late October remain in effect, with at least two employees receiving subpoenas for a proceeding scheduled Nov. 4, the day after the election. Federal marshals served one county employee at home despite having already served that employee at the registrar’s office and issued a notification of counsel, according to officials familiar with the incident.

The subpoenas demand copies of all internal communications about the Justice Department’s demands to county officials and the California secretary of state, plus all records involving the agency’s “methods for screening for unlawful voting by aliens” and “efforts to prevent noncitizen votes from being counted in any election.” California prosecutors arrested over 30 noncitizens in recent weeks on charges of illegally registering to vote, with some also accused of voting in previous elections.

The Trump administration had warned 57 of California’s 58 counties in late October to cooperate with federal investigations into illegal voting or face investigations themselves. Bill Essayli, the top federal prosecutor in Los Angeles, said before the election that “any election official who knowingly processes the ballot of a noncitizen is opening themselves to legal jeopardy.” Los Angeles County Registrar-Recorder Dean Logan responded that “at every step, the U.S. Department of Justice has taken a confrontational, adversarial approach.”

The DOJ has not responded to requests for comment on the dismissal or the ongoing grand jury proceedings. The department said in a Nov. 6 filing that it is “evaluating how to best ensure that American votes are protected, including by preventing vote dilution by noncitizens.”

The Breakdown

  • The Justice Department sued California in mid-October demanding election workers segregate roughly 20,000 mail ballots from people it claimed were noncitizens, after voting had already begun and hundreds of thousands of ballots had been processed.
  • U.S. District Judge David O. Carter rejected the request in late October, finding no feasible way to identify and segregate specific ballots without “catastrophic effects on the entire system.” A federal appeals panel upheld that denial Oct. 30.
  • The DOJ dismissed the lawsuit Nov. 6, telling the court that by the time of the next hearing, California would have already commingled the challenged ballots with lawful ones, making the requested relief impossible.
  • Federal grand jury subpoenas issued to Los Angeles County election officials in late October are in effect. The subpoenas demand all internal communications about the DOJ’s demands and all records involving methods for screening noncitizen voting.
  • California prosecutors arrested over 30 noncitizens in recent weeks on charges of illegally registering to vote. The Justice Department does not typically subpoena people it regards as targets to appear before a grand jury.
  • Studies have found noncitizen voting is very rare. Newly naturalized citizens are often mistakenly flagged as noncitizens, and there is no comprehensive list of U.S. citizens for verification.

What This Means for You

Federal executive-branch enforcement decisions — including which voter lists to compile, which ballots to challenge, and which local officials to threaten with prosecution — are directly shaped by the elected President’s administration. The lawsuit sought to block counting of ballots that had already been anonymized once processed — a technical impossibility Judge Carter cited in rejecting the government’s request. The dismissal came days after Republicans’ significant losses in the midterms.

What to Watch

The material does not state the total dollar cost of this litigation to California taxpayers, the Justice Department, or federal courts. The staffing, legal defense, and court time required to respond to a lawsuit filed after voting had already begun is taxpayer money spent — the amount is unavailable, and the case file, attorney billing records, or a public records request to the state attorney general’s office would show it.

The Justice Department has not disclosed the source or methodology behind its list of 20,000 alleged noncitizens. California officials said the list is out of date and includes legitimate voters; Judge Carter echoed that the list was unreliable.

The material does not state who compiled the list, what data sources were used, or whether any independent audit confirmed its accuracy before the DOJ filed suit. A coalition including the UCLA Voting Rights Project and the Coalition for Humane Immigrant Rights obtained the list under court order to evaluate its impact on eligible voters — that review would show whether the list disproportionately targeted naturalized citizens, as the plaintiffs alleged, or whether it accurately identified noncitizens as the DOJ claimed.

The grand jury subpoenas are in effect, but the material does not state who is being criminally investigated or whether election officials themselves are targets. The Justice Department does not typically subpoena people it regards as targets to appear before a grand jury, according to the material — if prosecutors intended to charge election officials with a crime, the subpoenas would likely have been structured differently.

Why did federal marshals serve one county employee at home after already serving that employee at the registrar’s office and issuing a notification of counsel? That timing and method raises the question of whether the service was intended to intimidate rather than to compel testimony — the answer would be in the U.S. Marshals Service’s justification for the second service, if one exists.

The 30-plus noncitizens arrested by California prosecutors in recent weeks were charged with illegally registering to vote, with some also accused of voting in previous elections. The material does not state how many of those 30-plus people were on the Justice Department’s list of 20,000, or whether any of the arrests resulted from the DOJ’s investigation rather than from routine state enforcement.

If the arrests were unrelated to the DOJ’s list, that would indicate the list added no investigative value beyond what California was already doing on its own — and if the arrests did stem from the list, that would be the first evidence in the material that the list led to confirmed cases rather than to disenfranchisement of citizens.

Related Coverage

Share this article Facebook X Pinterest LinkedIn Email

Leave a Reply

Advertisement Advertisement