ElectionsJusticeNational

Trump DOJ’s Voter-Roll Crusade Hits 0-28 Record in Court — But Subpoenas to California Counties Still Stand

The Trump administration’s effort to seize unredacted voter rolls from nearly every state, run them through federal citizenship databases, and tell states which voters to remove has lost every single court case decided so far — now 28 straight losses at the district-court level, including one from a judge Trump himself appointed. The Justice Department dropped its emergency lawsuit against California the week after Election Day, but it has not withdrawn the grand-jury subpoenas it sent to several California counties, including Los Angeles, Santa Clara, and Sonoma, demanding records about how local officials responded to federal orders to segregate ballots of people the DOJ flagged as possible noncitizens.

“It’s clear that there is this drive to try to conjure up facts that just don’t exist. I don’t think that’s going to change,” James Williams, county executive for California’s Santa Clara County, told NPR. “So we fully are prepared to continue to deal with this.”

At a Thursday press conference, U.S. Attorney General Todd Blanche said the department is not backing off. “We have ongoing cases and investigations in various states surrounding voter process,” Blanche said. “We are actively, and will continue to investigate election integrity cases criminally and civilly.”

Advertisement

Federal prosecutors announced criminal charges against dozens of people accused of voting or registering without citizenship in the weeks before Election Day. Compared to overall voter numbers, noncitizen voting is exceptionally rare — over the last twenty-five years, the percentage of fraudulent votes was 0.0000845%, according to Brookings, and no election outcome was altered by ballot fraud during that time. Yet the administration claimed it found 20,000 “likely” noncitizens on California’s voter rolls in mid-October.

A federal judge allowed UCLA’s Voting Rights Project to analyze that list the weekend before Election Day: the analysis found 42% of the names did not appear on California’s current voter roll at all, and naturalized citizens were on the list.

Santa Cruz County’s top election official, Tricia Webber, wrote in an email that of the 81 people the DOJ listed as suspected noncitizens registered in her county, “more than half are not registered in Santa Cruz County; some names do not match any person currently registered or previously registered,” and some dates of birth “were wildly inaccurate with some dates appearing well into the future like 2044.”

Two major court rulings blocked the DOJ’s program nationwide. On October 9, U.S. District Judge Sparkle Sooknanan vacated the DOJ’s entire “list maintenance project,” finding the department exceeded its statutory authority, violated federal privacy laws, and “has removed United States citizens from the voter rolls in their home states and risks disenfranchising many more.” The night before Election Day, a different federal judge in Washington, D.C., ruled that the DOJ and the Department of Homeland Security lack any statutory authority to distribute lists of purported noncitizens to election officials, and that doing so violates the Privacy Act.

The DOJ has appealed both rulings. Meanwhile, it has not rescinded the subpoenas sent to California counties in the days before Election Day. The October 21 subpoena sent to Los Angeles County, reviewed by NPR, requests records about how the registrar-recorder’s office screens for unlawful voting by noncitizens and records responding to federal demands to segregate ballots. In Sonoma, the subpoena is for records about an individual the DOJ alleges may have voted in a past election without being a U.S. citizen, as well as records about how county officials responded to DOJ requests to segregate ballots of people on its list, according to Sonoma County Counsel Joshua Myers.

The substance of the subpoenas has raised questions about whether there may be a criminal probe targeted at counties. In letters delivered to every California county in October, DOJ officials warned: “If persons knowingly tabulate ballots cast by individuals identified by federal agencies as noncitizens, they risk becoming aiders and abettors to a federal crime.” President Trump added on Truth Social: “They will all go to jail for a long period of time!!!”

Williams of Santa Clara County declined to speak about the subpoenas but said criminal threats against government employees trying to lawfully administer elections “strikes at the heart of what it means to live in a free society.”

Internal DOJ emails obtained by CNN and cited in a lawsuit show the department planned to keep some election officials in the dark about what it intended to do with unredacted state voter rolls, which contain private information including Social Security numbers, driver’s license numbers, and addresses. “I believe our reply should always be: ‘We will use the data in a manner consistent with Federal law’ and say nothing more,” Eric Neff, the current leader of the DOJ voting section, wrote in a November 2025 email discussing a letter from Democratic state officials that asked about plans to upload the data to DHS’s citizenship-check system.

At least 18 states voluntarily turned over their full voter files to the DOJ, according to court filings. The department shared that data with DHS, which ran it through the federal SAVE database to check citizenship status. States participating in the program agreed that if DOJ flagged voters as potentially ineligible, they would “clean” their voter rolls within 45 days and remove those voters before resubmitting updated files to the department. Judge Sooknanan found that the DOJ failed to adequately consider the risk that the citizenship databases it relied on could misidentify eligible U.S. citizens as noncitizens, noting that federal records may be outdated for people who became citizens after first receiving Social Security numbers and that millions of citizens have historically been misclassified in federal records.

The DOJ sued 31 states and Washington, D.C., for their voter rolls when officials refused to turn over unredacted data. All 28 district-court decisions have dismissed the lawsuits. On November 7, U.S. District Judge David Barlow, a Trump nominee, dismissed the DOJ’s lawsuit against Utah with prejudice, ruling that Utah’s statewide voter registration list falls outside the scope of Title III of the Civil Rights Act of 1960, the law DOJ has repeatedly invoked. “An ordinary English speaker would not say that she has come into possession of something that she created, established, and maintained,” Barlow wrote.

With Democrats winning control of Congress in the midterm elections, lawmakers could hold hearings probing how federal officials came up with their list, said David Becker, executive director for the Center for Election Innovation and Research. “I think we’re going to have some very serious scrutiny of the Department of Homeland Security and their methodology as they assisted the administration in its failed effort to try to demonstrate there was widespread noncitizen voting in this country,” Becker said.

The Breakdown

  • The DOJ demanded unredacted voter rolls from 49 states and D.C., seeking information including Social Security numbers, driver’s license numbers, and addresses, claiming it needed the data to enforce federal election laws requiring states to maintain voter lists.
  • At least 18 states voluntarily turned over their files. The DOJ shared that data with DHS, which ran it through the SAVE database (a federal citizenship-verification system) and told states to remove flagged voters within 45 days.
  • The DOJ sued 31 states and D.C. that refused. All 28 district-court decisions dismissed the lawsuits, with courts finding the DOJ exceeded its statutory authority and violated privacy laws.
  • On October 9, a federal judge vacated the DOJ’s entire nationwide program. The night before Election Day, a different judge ruled the DOJ and DHS lack authority to distribute lists of purported noncitizens to election officials and that doing so violates the Privacy Act.
  • The DOJ dropped its emergency California lawsuit after Election Day but has not withdrawn grand-jury subpoenas sent to several California counties, including Los Angeles, Santa Clara, and Sonoma, demanding records about how local officials responded to federal orders.
  • Analysis of the DOJ’s California list of 20,000 “likely” noncitizens found 42% did not appear on the current voter roll, naturalized citizens were on the list, and some dates of birth were “wildly inaccurate,” including dates “well into the future like 2044.”

What This Means for You

The DOJ is still pursuing the counties that administer your elections with grand-jury subpoenas and criminal threats, even after losing in court and dropping its lawsuit. Two federal judges have already ruled the program unlawful. The DOJ sent counties a list that analysis showed included names not on the current voter roll, naturalized U.S. citizens, and impossible birth dates, then demanded counties remove the flagged voters within 45 days or face criminal prosecution. County officials who refused those demands — which courts later ruled the DOJ had no authority to issue — now face subpoenas asking how they responded to the federal orders.

With Democrats winning control of Congress in the midterm elections, lawmakers could hold hearings on how the administration compiled these lists and whether federal officials violated the Privacy Act by using voter data without required public notice, according to David Becker of the Center for Election Innovation and Research.

What to Watch

The DOJ has appealed both major rulings against its voter-roll program, and it has not withdrawn the subpoenas sent to California counties. That means two questions are live right now: whether appellate courts will uphold the district-court findings that the program is unlawful, and whether federal prosecutors will actually bring criminal charges against county election officials for refusing orders that courts have already ruled the DOJ had no authority to issue in the first place. The material does not state what specific evidence a grand jury has been asked to review, or whether any county official is formally a target rather than merely a records custodian, but the October letters from DOJ officials warning that county workers “risk becoming aiders and abettors to a federal crime” if they count ballots from people the federal government flagged make the criminal-prosecution threat explicit.

The federal government generated lists that demonstrably misidentified naturalized citizens and included impossible data, sent those lists to counties with a 48-hour deadline, threatened criminal prosecution if counties did not comply, and then issued grand-jury subpoenas after the counties refused.

The DOJ has not published the methodology it used to compile the 20,000-name California list, has not stated how many of the people on that list were in fact eligible voters, and has not explained how a list that included future birth dates and names not on the current voter roll at all could support a criminal case. If the incoming Congress holds hearings, those are the records to demand: the actual methodology, the error rate, and whether anyone inside DOJ or DHS raised concerns about accuracy before the lists were sent to counties with criminal threats attached.

Attorney General Todd Blanche said the department will continue to investigate “election integrity cases criminally and civilly,” but so far the only documented “integrity” problem is the federal government’s own data. The question for California voters is whether county officials can be prosecuted for refusing to follow orders that courts ruled illegal — and whether the public will ever see the evidence, or lack of it, that supposedly justified the orders in the first place.

Related Coverage

Share this article Facebook X Pinterest LinkedIn Email

Leave a Reply

Advertisement Advertisement